You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Arabia
Editorial: Against Suicide Bombings
2003-10-07
Unsigned editorial in Arab News. I can see why it's unsigned...
Israel's attack on what it said was an Islamic Jihad military training camp in Syria sends two messages to the world. The first, on behalf of the United States, is the clear signal that the Bush administration will do everything it can to keep Syria and Iran in its sights as the so-called war on terror continues. It is a message that has been heard, loud and clear, in the Arab world.
I don't hear a lot of Arab governments howling to protect Syria yet...
However, the second message, though indirect, should be taken on board with equal concern: That suicide attacks on Israeli civilian targets are politically and militarily counterproductive.
Starting to sink in, is it? Not wrong or anything, just counterproductive...
How much reflection has there been in the Arab media on the fact that three Israeli Arabs were among the 19 killed in the restaurant in Haifa on Saturday? How much acknowledgement has there been that the city targeted is one of the few in Israel where Arabs and Jews coexist peacefully? And where are the editorials asking what the three children and the baby who were blown to pieces there did to deserve such a terrible fate?
Rantissi says he wants to kill them all...
Is there any reflection on the fact that Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat is now as a result of the bombing in a weaker position than ever, and that the sizeable minority of ordinary Americans who support Palestinian calls for a viable state are less likely than ever to raise their voices in support of the cause?
The sizeable minority who favor a Paleostinian state is much larger than the minority that actively supports the Paleostinians...
Arab News has said it before, but along with all decent-minded people we must continue to say it loudly and unambiguously: Suicide bombings are morally repugnant, are totally against Islam and all human decency.
Wow. Took my breath away. See why it's unsigned?
The suicide bombings are part and parcel of the impotence and desperation that in so many ways characterizes the Arab condition. Many say that it is precisely because of this impotence that suicide bombers are forced to carry out their attacks. But the opposite is true: Each suicide bombing deals another blow to the already immeasurably weakened Arab position.
Even managed to work in some cause->effect...
Let's face it: The Palestinians and the wider Arab world have no meaningful strategy for dealing with the Arab-Israeli conflict, and that is why extremism fills the vacuum. If as much planning and effort had been put into forging a strategy for mass civil disobedience, for example, and promoting genuine internal reform and development as has been put into the recruitment, training and encouragement of suicide bombers, the Palestinians would not only be in a much stronger position at the negotiating table but would also have much more vocal and tangible support from the international community.
Bingo. But they go for the corpses...
That Israel was able to attack a camp just a few miles outside Damascus, without having to worry about the risks involved or the possibility of reprisals, is a clear indication of Arab impotence.
Bashar's been shown to be more mouth than artillery...
Will the Arabs ever see the link between self-defeating act of suicide bombing and their self-destructive activities on the diplomatic level whenever they attempt to address the Middle East conflict?
Probably not. If they ever do, they problem will be solved within a few years.
Posted by:Fred Pruitt

#10  Great Kerath's ghost! Even anonymous, that's still a lot of guts! Way 2 go, anonymous Arab!
Posted by: Atrus   2003-10-7 2:13:36 PM  

#9  Half Full - no more suicide bombing
Half Empty - Non-suicide bombings and missile/machine gun attacks on school buses continue.
Posted by: Superhose   2003-10-7 12:25:59 PM  

#8  Things will not change overnight, and it is rather dispiriting that a sensible piece such as this has to be submitted unsigned, but the fact that these sentiments are being given expression in the Arab Press is hopeful. The acknowlegement that a culture that venerates the murderous nihilism of suicide bombers is just reveling in its impotence is long overdue. Here's to hoping that these ideas get some traction.
Posted by: af   2003-10-7 12:21:20 PM  

#7  signed: Mohammed Abbas
Posted by: Frank G   2003-10-7 11:31:48 AM  

#6  Suicide bombings are morally repugnant, are totally against Islam and all human decency.


Nice sentiment, but as long as an Arab must remain anonymous to write them, things won't change.
Posted by: Dar   2003-10-7 10:26:19 AM  

#5  RC - Just FYI: I definitely agree that actions are all that matter - as I said in closing...

However, I read the Green Truth everday for almost 3 years in S.A. and never saw them openly admit that Arabs were "impotent" (or anything akin to such an admission) nor did they ever imply that they had no strategy, for that is a direct criticism of the leadership. Though the info in this piece is obvious to us, this is well beyond anything I've ever seen before. Any item that might imply a negative perception of the Royals, for example, had a corresponding plausible (by Saudi reckoning, anyway) Non-Royal scapegoat identified.

I find this language to be unique for the AN.

I'll join you in waiting for the actions necessary to address the points raised. I've got the chips & beer - can you cover the salsa and wine coolers? ;^)
Posted by: .com   2003-10-7 9:47:54 AM  

#4  Uh, sorry, but this means about as much as a bucket of spit poured into the ocean. Not only is it in the wrong language, but it's in a paper owned by the Soddy Roils -- and they have a desperate need to appear moderate.

I'll believe it when they go a year of Fridays without asking Allah to destroy the Jews.
Posted by: Robert Crawford   2003-10-7 7:02:38 AM  

#3  Holy Shit! Made me swallow my gum! Fred, are you writing anonymously for the Green Truth, now? Wow.

While JFM & TT are correct in their comments as well, it is a no-shit Thunderbolt of the Coming Apolcalypse for this to make it into print - in any language - in the AN. It doesn't matter that there is some minor quibbling and prevarication, this is a true moment in the sun for a major Arab publication:
More Reality than Phantasy.

Mestunned! Now, let's see if it means anything, as truth lies in acts, not words. Thx, Fred!
Posted by: .com   2003-10-7 4:16:18 AM  

#2  Yeah. Someone has got to translate this into the language that terrorists and their supporters understand:

"Les attaques de Israel sur....

Anyone around here who can write French?

Of course it couldn't hurt to see this in Arabic, Farsi, Urdu and a few others too.
Posted by: Tokyo Taro   2003-10-7 4:03:11 AM  

#1  It is step. However in Arab media it is common to have two versions: one in English calling to peace and one in Arabic with an entirely differnt content.
Posted by: JFM   2003-10-7 1:46:14 AM  

00:00