| Submit your comments on this article |
| Europe |
| Germans Meet Wyatt Earp at Conference, Learn to be afraid very afraid |
| 2003-09-12 |
| from Victorino Matus an assistant managing editor at The Weekly Standard. Scottsdale, Arizona Snip The Hyatt Gainey Ranch played host last month to the 25th annual American-German Young Leaders conference. Sponsored by the American Council on Germany and Atlantik-BrÃŒcke, the confab brought together a dynamic group of young Germans and Americans from the fields of government, business, and the media. The theme was "Assessing the U.S.-German Relationship: A Partnership Amid Tensions," and for four days we debated the future role of the United Nations, the lessons of Iraq, and the global economy. Snip But the key moment came at a lunch with Joe Arpaio, Maricopa County’s meanest and toughest sheriff, and one of the most shameless self-promoters in America, which is saying something. ARPAIO is known in Arizona for his "Tent City," in which inmates live outdoors ("just like our troops in the Middle East," he points out), eat reduced-calorie meals, and wear pink underwear. He also boasted about his chain-gangs, which line the highways picking up trash. Women serve on the chain-gang, too, he told us, since he’s a big believer in equal rights. And then there was the time inmates were forced to eat green bologna. And on and on and on. Most of the Americans listening to his rant laughed incredulously and brushed off his pronouncements as exaggerations meant for shock value. The Germans, however, were horrified. Underwear in his prison is dyed pink. Pillferage of underwear was a major budget buster for his operation until they began dying it a color that lacked "street cred." Underwear stopped disappearing. I think there was also an element of rebellion in his choice of pink. How can you run a sucessful rehabilitation facility where petty theft by the criminals is tolerated? "Disgusting," said one, loud enough for other tables to hear. A few even walked out. Several Germans dared to question the sheriff about recidivism rates (Arpaio had no concrete numbers) and accountability ("I have no boss" other than the voters, he explained). But having heard it all before, Arpaio was ready with comebacks, wisecracks, and retorts. When he concluded his speech, the controversy spilled out into the lobby, where some Germans, a few members of the Bundestag in particular, were engaged in a heated debate about human rights violations and questionable comparisons to East Germany (and wondering why they were subjected to Arpaio in the first place). The result was an ad hoc session contrasting the differences between American and German values. Some of the German delegates were genuinely angry not only at Arpaio’s remarks, but that he was a featured speaker. There were dark warnings that Arpaio’s electoral success did not bode well for America. "We are going down the road to tyranny. The United States is losing its attraction as a role model of democracy for the world," exclaimed one delegate. Another was disturbed by the Americans laughing at Arpaio’s snarky comments. Another felt an all-too-familiar onus: "I feel guilty for not having stood up to him," he said. The Americans were, for the most part, silent and taken aback. A few chimed in to explain that Arpaio is famous for exaggeration. Some tried to reassure the Germans that the sheriff was not a sign of things to come--that the nation still has safeguards to prevent the rise of a dictator. Nevertheless, one of the larger issues was the apparent divergence concerning the rights of criminals. "It’s not that we don’t share the same values," explained one American, "but we do have different experiences. From the time of our Founders, we’ve placed a lot of weight on the individual and liberty." Another American provided a better context, explaining that the rise of Joe Arpaio and his methods came at a time in the early 1990s when crime rates were dangerously high. "I underestimated the German response," said Elmar Thevessen, news director for ZDF television. "I thought they would book it under the ’wild, wild west’ stereotype. But they took offense because of our deep belief in human dignity." Thevessen is familiar with Sheriff Joe since he visited Tent City in 1996. "It is true Arpaio puts on a little show every time he speaks. But by the same token he represents a system of humiliation that extends far beyond the unusual treatment of the detainees." Thevessen was sure to clarify that he wasn’t soft on crime. "’Being tough on criminals’--I am all for it! But violating the principle of human dignity--which was instilled into the German constitution by our American friends--is not the right way for a democracy to achieve its goals and protect its values." Not that all Germans felt as strongly. "There is so much worse out there in the world," said one German. "And besides, you should see some German prisons. They aren’t exactly the greatest either." The vociferous German reaction, though surprising, should be welcomed. It is a good thing that the Germans of today hold human rights and dignity so close to their hearts. (Would we prefer they instead embrace order and conformity?) THE NEXT DAY, several delegates took Arpaio up on his offer to visit the prison. According to one German, there were no signs of human rights violations and that given a choice between living in an indoors facility or on the tent grounds, she would opt for the latter. (This did, however, upset some of her colleagues who felt she was playing into the hands of Arpaio by having visited the jail at all.) Snip I’m sure that the German delegates will return to their country with many stories about the evil warden of shanty town jail. |
| Posted by:Super Hose |
| #8 I'd bet my left nut he's a Repooplican--playing to the lowest common denominator in the American sheeple--giving the Yahoos a Springer moment they can revel in. I bet O'Reilly loves him! |
| Posted by: Not Mike Moore 2003-9-12 11:27:01 PM |
| #7 John I think I have seen the same documentaries that you have. His system seems to be valid for petty offenders. Being a popular politician, he presents no documentation of his results. No need to as the voters are happy that his program isn't sucking local taxz dollars like otehr programs tend to. His results can't be miserable, though, as I'm sure his opponents have sponsored studies to undercut what he is doing. Would love to the the EU or UN take on his operation. |
| Posted by: Super Hose 2003-9-12 8:24:27 PM |
| #6 Sherrif Arpaio has been in the news for this stuff before, but any serious look at his operation seems to conclude he is doing strange but valid things. Like those tents: the prison did not have sufficient room to house prisoners in anything approaching humane conditions, so rather than what some other places have done - turn out prisoners arbitrarily - he found a way to cope. Unusual, but not cruel, and not circumventing the sentences imposed by the courts. Now, "This did, however, upset some of her colleagues who felt she was playing into the hands of Arpaio by having visited the jail at all." Huh? Would they have felt that way if she had come back with stories of over-the-line treatments rather than just off-the-wall? Instead, "given a choice between living in an indoors facility or on the tent grounds, she would opt for the latter." Ooh, how horrible, she must have been brain-washed! |
| Posted by: John Anderson 2003-9-12 6:21:02 PM |
| #5 Nope, I was too busy alerting Amnesty International about the "pink cruel and unusual punishment". I mean, executing people is bad enough but THIS is so over the top! Btw, nothing about it in the German press. |
| Posted by: True German Ally 2003-9-12 5:30:08 PM |
| #4 But did they take any underwear???? TGA, would you mind posting any stories you find? |
| Posted by: Anonymous 2003-9-12 2:43:47 PM |
| #3 Love'm or hate him, this guy is old hat, except maybe to the Germans. This actually sounds like fun. |
| Posted by: Hiryu 2003-9-12 11:21:21 AM |
| #2 God I hope he spoke like Foghorn Leghorn. |
| Posted by: Shipman 2003-9-12 11:04:11 AM |
| #1 And the Europeans thought Rumsfeld was scary......heh heh heh! |
| Posted by: Baba Yaga 2003-9-12 10:16:41 AM |