[CATO] Once you notice this pattern of regulation and resiliency you begin seeing it every day. Yesterday, in a piece of truly welcome news, it was announced that the Food and Drug Administration has approved the first at‐home test for COVID-19, from laboratory giant LabCorp. At‐home testing, with its potential for speed and convenience, holds great promise for making up lost time in the area the feds most thoroughly botched in responding to the pandemic; a version of it also figures in Bill Gates’ ambitious plans to combat the virus in Seattle and beyond. Early, limited supplies will initially be made available for two of the kinds of workers who need it most, health care staff and first responders, who will be able to obtain their results online with no need to go through a doctor’s office.
If you go to the LabCorp site promoting the new kit, however, you’ll notice a warning: “Not available in MD, NJ, NY, and RI.” As it happens, Maryland, New Jersey, New York, and Rhode Island are four of the states hardest‐hit by the virus. As the Associated Press explains today: “Those states have laws prohibiting testing with at‐home sample collection kits, according to LabCorp.” [Update: a Maryland health official says notwithstanding the AP description, his state’s law does not ban the home kit.]
Why? As a Maryland resident, I know only too well that my state’s legislature is like those in states like New York and New Jersey in having deep‐seated interventionist and regulatory instincts. (These often bring it into conflict with Gov. Larry Hogan (R), who tends to favor a lighter touch.) But why ban home testing in the first place? This 2017 Technology Review article gives some background, following a controversy over an abortive plan to distribute free genetic tests to fans at a Baltimore Ravens game at M&T Stadium. It says “Maryland and New York’s laws are meant to protect consumers from companies making dubious claims about DNA tests and also make sure people receive proper advice and counseling from their doctors about their medical results.” |