You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
-Short Attention Span Theater-
Here's what would happen if an Abrams tank got hit by a battleship shell
2018-05-03
The M1A2 Abrams main battle tank is arguably the best in the world. Yeah, Russia is generating some hype for the Armata family of tanks, but the Abrams is combat-proven and very hard to kill.

How hard? Well, in his 1994 non-fiction book, "Armored Cav," Tom Clancy recounted a tale of how an M1A1 Abrams got stuck in the mud during the ground war of Desert Storm. It was then set upon by three tanks, Iraqi T-72s specifically.

A round fired from roughly a thousand yards away bounced off, and the Abrams responded by blowing the T-72 that fired it to bits. A second round fired from 700 yards bounced off, and the offending T-72 was blasted. The third T-72, at a range of roughly 400 yards, fired a round, which left a groove in the armor of the Abrams. It, too, was destroyed by a shot fired through a sand berm. These were, supposedly, Russia's state-of-the-art tanks.

Then, when help arrived, and the tank couldn't be freed from the mud, a platoon of Abrams tanks tried to destroy it.

After several rounds, they detonated the onboard ammo, but the blow-out panels functioned as designed. Then, when the tank was retrieved from the mud, they discovered that it was still functional. The only issue? A sight was out of alignment.

So, what would it take to reliably destroy an M1 Abrams? Well, someone at quora.com asked what would happen if an Abrams was hit by a round from a 16-inch gun on an American Iowa-class battleship.

The 16-inch armor-piercing rounds fired from the battleship weigh in at 2,700 pounds. The 120mm rounds fired at that Abrams stuck in the mud? They're about 20 pounds.

Do a quick bit of math and you'll see that the Iowa's main gun round is 135 times as heavy as an Abrams' main gun round. The Abrams may be the world's toughest tank and can take a ton of abuse, but not this level of abuse.

To put it simply, a main gun round from the Iowa-class battleship will destroy the Abrams easily. In a way, this speaks well for the Abrams ‐ one can't really imagine anything short of an Iowa's main gun being able to destroy one.
Posted by:gorb

#7  Speaking of targets on the Left Coast, after I had finished with Hollyweird and West LA, I think it might be a real knee-slapper to toodle on up the coast and take a couple of potshots at Pelosi's digs and DiFi's Manse.

Watching the drone videos of San Fran Nan's smoldering ruin would warm the cockles of my black little heart.
Posted by: Sock Puppet of Doom   2018-05-03 23:52  

#6  AlanC, 1) How much would you lend me? 2) I have nothing against fish, or Catalina, so I got a little more into the landward possibilities than was probably healthy. First thought was (naturally) a broadside at Malibu, but that's hopeless, assuming 24 mi range. Ditto the Hollywood Sign. Hollywood & Vine? Maybe barely, but that'd break Rantburg rules. Dodger Stadium (empty, of course) presents the dreadful possibility of a shortfall on Chinatown, City Hall, or even Skid Row. Various hillsides and golf courses? Kinda boring. So let's say Santa Monica: Over Torrance or whatever and straight up several miles of beach (does the 4th work for you?), over the Pier, and kersplash. Goosebumps I've got.
Posted by: Zenobia Floger6220   2018-05-03 22:57  

#5  #3 - Excellent Snark
Posted by: Frank G   2018-05-03 21:25  

#4  ZF,

1) How much would you pay to pick the target?
2) Who gets the drone's video of the damage?

That would be some serious fun.
Posted by: AlanC   2018-05-03 20:00  

#3  I would have thought the Russian tanks had dashcams.
Posted by: Thing From Snowy Mountain   2018-05-03 18:01  

#2  hopping for a video

Cheerful image, that. Just squirming in my chair, myself. Got me wondering what it might be like if Iowa were to fire a round out to sea once in a while. Weekly, say. Standing room in the turret? Messages scribbled on a shell? I'm crazy cheap and I'd pay an embarrassing amount of money for that. Probably turn a profit. I know it can't happen, and more or less why it can't, but wow... if I ran the zoo!
Posted by: Zenobia Floger6220   2018-05-03 17:47  

#1  I was hopping for a video.
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2018-05-03 13:11  

00:00