You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: WoT
Bradley Manning sues over denial of gender dysphoria treatment
2014-09-28
The Guardian, the ACLU, and even the US government feels obliged to refer to Bradley as 'Chelsea' but I'm under no such obligation. Bradley is a biological male, and "gender dysphoria" is a made-up diagnosis ginned up as part of our society's current fetish towards the 57 different genders. "Testosterone poisoning" also is a foolish neologism, though I can understand how many progressive males would fear it...
I have gender dyspepsia, which is an acute case of the rectal clench when people natter on about "gender issues." If you have "gender issues" tell your Mom. The rest of the world has no obligation to be interested.
Chelsea Manning, the US army soldier who released hundreds of thousands of secret documents to WikiLeaks, has filed a lawsuit in a federal court that charges her military jailers with violating her constitutional rights by denying medical treatment for gender dysphoria.

The legal complaint, lodged with a US district court in Washington DC, accuses the army of repeatedly ignoring her pleas for appropriate treatment for her condition. It names as defendants: the secretary of defence Chuck Hagel, major general David Quantock of the army corrections command, and colonel Erica Nelson who commands the disciplinary barracks in Fort Leavenworth, Kansas, where Manning is held.

“Every day that goes by without appropriate treatment, [Manning] experiences escalating anxiety, distress and depression. She feels as though her body is being poisoned by testosterone,” the suit says.
Bradley is one mixed up man. In a more just world he'd be locked away in a secure facility and undergo appropriate psychiatric treatment.
Manning reminds me of Mike Penner, the Los Angeles sportswriter who "tried to fight being a woman" and decided to go for the sex change. He later killed himself, and his newspaper, the Los Angeles Times had an article sanctimoniously entitled in part, "Private Torment" It was such a waste because he would not come to terms with his gender and sought expensive help which in the end did nothing.
Lt Col Alayne Conway, an army spokeswoman, said that as a matter of policy the military did not comment on pending litigation.

Manning was first diagnosed as having gender dysphoria "formerly known as gender identity disorder" in May 2010, just days before she was arrested at the Forward Operating Base Hammer outside Baghdad where she was stationed as a US army intelligence analyst. She is now serving a 35-year sentence in military custody for crimes related to the massive WikiLeaks dump of state secrets.
Bradley is desperate both to obscure that little sentencing issue and keep himself in the news. The progressives are willing to use him the same way they've used many other mixed up people.
Last September she was again diagnosed with gender dysphoria "in her case, the innate sense of being female even though her sex at birth was male" by Dr Ellen Galloway, chief of the mental health division at the disciplinary barracks. Yet despite making numerous requests for treatment, none has been forthcoming.
They don't do hip replacements on demand, either. And be careful not to catch cancer in federal prison.
In July, the Associated Press reported that Hagel had given the green light to “rudimentary” treatment, but since then the only concession the military has made is to allow her to wear female underwear and sports bras. Meanwhile, she has not been allowed to express her female gender outwardly by growing her hair longer or through other forms of grooming customary for female prisoners.
Because she is still a he and will remain a he for quite a while yet...
She has also been denied the other pillars of gender dysphoria treatment, the lawsuit states, including specialist psychotherapy, hormone therapy and surgery to change her primary and/or secondary sex characteristics. The suit makes the chilling warning that “gender dysphoria intensifies over time. Incarcerated individuals, particularly male-to-female transsexuals like [Manning], are at a particularly high risk of engaging in self-harm including self-castration when treatment is withheld.”
We could leave a dull kitchen knife behind on his food tray...
Chase Strangio, a staff attorney with the ACLU which is representing Manning in the legal action, said in a statement that it had become clear that her treatment had been “governed not by doctors but by Washington officials and dictated not by medicine but by politics”. He added that “treating severe gender dysphoria with sports bras is like treating a gunshot wound with a Band-Aid”.
The Army is not obligated to "treat" this at all.
The ACLU argues that the withholding of treatment is a breach of clear rules for responding to gender issues such as Manning's set out by the World Professional Association for Transgender Health.
Who? Is that another progressive funded organization?
The lawsuit contains an account of Manning's personal struggle with her condition. “From a young age she experienced the persistent sense that she was "different". In school she was teased and called names such as "girly-boy", "faggy" and "queer" because she did not conform to expectations of how a boy should look and act.”

It was only in 2009, shortly before she was posted to Iraq, that she came to terms with being a transgender woman. She first made public her gender identity the day after she was sentenced in August 2013. Through her lawyer David Coombs she told NBC television: “I am Chelsea Manning. I am a female.”
Whatever you are in your head, Bradley, you're a biological male and that's how the Army should treat you until you're released. Then we'll see how good your current "friends" are...
Posted by:Steve White

#12  Nothing a firing squad cant help. Traitor.
Posted by: newc   2014-09-28 22:50  

#11  Someone screwed up and got the pronouns in this story wrong. They used "her" for a guy.
Posted by: Rob Crawford   2014-09-28 20:16  

#10  Not to mention that women naturally produce testosterone too. So there is no such thing as testosterone poisoning.

I like Tholuns Poodle's hacksaw solution best.

Al
Posted by: frozen al   2014-09-28 16:56  

#9  One thing this does highlight is this...

How lax is recruitment when this obvious loon get access to classified stuff?
Posted by: Bright Pebbles   2014-09-28 16:50  

#8  The faster this idiot is rendered carbon neutral the better.
Posted by: DarthVader   2014-09-28 12:45  

#7  ..have an outpatient call from the Phoenix VA?
Posted by: Procopius2k   2014-09-28 12:19  

#6  Until veterans are receiving proper care, you wait Manning. And FYI its not poisoning, your body makes testosterone naturally - that Y chromosome makes you MALE no matter what the headshrinkers and lawyers tell you.

TL;DR? Back of the line fuckwit traitor.
Posted by: OldSpook   2014-09-28 12:13  

#5  
Posted by: Bright Pebbles   2014-09-28 12:08  

#4  Once Bradley gets out of prison (if he does), he can do whatever the hell he wants about his so-called gender disorder. Meanwhile, do your time, without the whining and complaints.
Posted by: JohnQC   2014-09-28 11:01  

#3  So Bradley /(slash) Chelsea Manning hasn't had his (slash) her sex change operation yet... and has gender dysphoria ....hmmm...

gender dysphoria
noun
A persistent unease with having the physical characteristics of one's gender, accompanied by strong identification with the opposite gender and a desire to live as or to become a member of the opposite gender.

In July, Hagel had given the green light to “rudimentary” treatment...

Sounds to me like Hagel was hinting Manning should be assigned with prison kitchen duties...


Posted by: Tholuns Poodle7378   2014-09-28 10:12  

#2  Easy one. What box did he/she tick in his/her Army application form? Male or female? Matter resolved.
Posted by: European Conservative   2014-09-28 03:29  

#1  Excellent in-lines. Spot on, each one. Apologies to the Rosenbergs. Manning should have been executed long ago.
Posted by: Besoeker   2014-09-28 02:36  

00:00