You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Submit your comments on this article
Israel-Palestine-Jordan
Intifada far off
2013-03-15
[Ynet] Arab columnist says Paleostinians will revolt against 'occupation' when they reach state of utter despair

Over the past few weeks an extensive discussion has been held regarding the possibility that the protest against the occupation in the West Bank will escalate into a full-blown intifada. Israel has contributed greatly to this discussion. The heads of the security services in Israel instructed forces to do whatever is necessary to prevent the outbreak of another intifada, which will bring an end to calm and pleasant reality of the occupation in the West Bank.

To this end, the Israeli government has transferred to the Paleostinian Authority the tax revenues it had confiscated, instructed the army to avoid excessive oppression and killing and urged the Paleostinian leadership to prevent the situation from deteriorating.

Israel fears another initidafa, be it an armed uprising or a popular one, because it would expose its true face as a racist and conquering force.
Yeah, yeah.
Such an intifada would unite the Paleostinian people, its political forces and leadership. An uprising would shore up Arab and international support for the Paleostinian cause and prompt regional and international forces to prevent further escalation.

But an intifada has yet to erupt for the following reasons:

First of all, due to the political and geographical division, the Paleostinians concentrate all of their energy on internal struggles, sectoral interests and competition between the various factions. This was evident over the past few weeks when Hamas, always the voice of sweet reason, called to expand the protest while the PA urged restraint. Therefore, an end to internal Paleostinian division is one of the conditions for the eruption of a popular uprising. Such an intifada may not be initiated by the key Paleostinian movements, but without them it will not be continuous and will not lead to victory.

Secondly, the lack of a Paleostinian strategy reduces the likelihood of an intifada. The strategy of negotiating with Israel reached a dead end years ago. The armed resistance strategy has also been suspended. The Paleostinian leadership went to the UN, but it does not have a new general strategy. Hamas' strategy of "tahadiya after tahadiya" (calm after calm) is not long-lasting and cannot lead to victory.

Moreover, the leadership, mainly in Ramallah, fears that an intifada may spin out of control and lead to the collapse of the Paleostinian Authority. This is why it preferred the tactic of controllable popular protests.

In addition, the current socioeconomic situation, which encourages the culture of consumption,
That is to say, improved prosperity...
blocks elements of resistance and protest. The way of life in the West Bank and Gazoo, and particularly in Ramallah, has created a gap between the leaders and the people. It has also created individuals and groups, within and outside the Authority, who are against an intifada because it would not serve their interests. They will object to an uprising or refrain from supporting it.
Good for them.
The fifth reason is that the Paleostinian people are suffering from the repercussions of the loss of the uniting national project and the petrifaction of their national institutions, as well as the erosion of these institutions' legitimacy.
Golly. Such fancy, scientific words.
This led to the spread of individualism, nepotism, corruption, sectionalism and to the loss of the people's faith in the institutions.
Wow. Somebody bought a dictionary.
Another reason is that, seemingly, the Paleostinian people will think a million times before launching an intifada, as they cannot ignore the fact that the casualties and suffering during an intifada are always greater than the achievements.
Indeed. Clever of them all to notice.
If we add this insight to the corruption in the PA, we can understand why the simple and poor citizen would say: "I am not going to sacrifice myself or my sons so that the fruits of this sacrifice will be enjoyed by those who are not willing to sacrifice themselves or their sons."

An intifada will erupt only when the people will have hope, or reach a state of utter despair. Currently there is not a lot of hope, but we are not in a state of total despair either. This is why, for now, all we are seeing are seasonal and local waves of protest.

No one knows when the next intifada will break out. But, sooner or later, it will.
Or not, as the case may be. That much can be predicted of a surety.
Hani al-Masri
"The Egyptian?" And now he is a Palestinian...
is a Paleostinian political analyst and an independent columnist for several Paleostinian and Arab papers. His article was published in the Paleostinian news agency Sama and was translated to Hebrew as part of a project initiated by the Van Leer Jerusalem Institute and the I`lam Media Center for Arab Paleostinians in Israel in Nazareth
Posted by:trailing wife

#5  Israel fears another initidafa, be it an armed uprising or a popular one, because it would expose its true face as a racist and conquering force

exactly what race are they suppressing, asshole? It's not hard to be a conquering force when you're fighting Arabs
Posted by: Frank G   2013-03-15 10:26  

#4  bugaboo
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2013-03-15 09:28  

#3  I would tend to agree Grom, but wiping people out still seems to be a bugaboo for Jews.
Couldn't imagine why.
Posted by: bigjim-CA   2013-03-15 09:08  

#2  No one knows when the next intifada will break out. But, sooner or later, it will.

Nobody knows when the next outbreak of cockroaches will occur. But this time we're going to fumigate --- solve the problem once and for all.
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2013-03-15 07:27  

#1   they cannot ignore the fact that the casualties and suffering during an intifada are always greater than the achievements.

Oh, don't be such wussies! Where's that good ol' jihadi "we love death more than you love life" spirit? There is nothing more glorious and Arabic than colossal failure. You'll be able to tell the story for generations.
Posted by: SteveS   2013-03-15 02:31  

00:00