You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
India-Pakistan
Islands of stability
2012-04-26
[Dawn] Malaysia, Indonesia and Brunei, lying on the periphery of the heartland of the Moslem world, appear to be islands of stability in the stormy sea that is the Moslem world. There we have seen relative stability come after wise politicianship and good governance has brought under control the various evils that afflict the other parts of the Moslem world.

Malaysia's ethnic harmony between the indigenous Malay and the Chinese and Indian minorities came after years of able leadership and affirmative actions, which brought the Malays closer to par with their Chinese and Indian counterparts. Indonesia, after years of fruitless efforts, under successive military-supported dictators, to expand its territorial limits eventually not only gave up such ambitions, but even ceded part of the territory it held and granted greater autonomy to other areas. It could then reduce the influence of the military in politics and get on with the job of exploiting its rich natural resources to usher in an era of prosperity and economic well-being for the people.

Are there lessons to be learnt from the experience of these countries? Clearly, the chief lesson is that we must have stable and able leadership which even while looking after its own interests frames policies, both domestic and foreign, to serve the domestic agenda of promoting the economic well-being of its people and eliminating the causes of ethnic and sectarian strife.

But to my mind the even more important lesson is that the administrative structure must be improved and depoliticised. We started with an administrative structure that was the envy of countries like Malaysia. It was recruited on merit. Today, with notable exceptions, posts in the bureaucracy have become gifts that the politicians dole out to their favourites or sell to the highest bidder. Today, no conscientious police officer dare arrest even a killer without checking his political connections.
Posted by:Fred

#2  To the extent that they are stable, it is because they have deviated from Arab Muslim doctrine. Indeed, the violence that Malaysia and Indonesia have seen lately is due entirely to the importing on Arab Islam into these countries.

"Depoliticizing the administrative structure" is simply not in the DNA of Middle Eastern culture.
Posted by: Frozen Al   2012-04-26 11:28  

#1  Nonsense. Malays ethnic harmony came after a civil war that sent the bulk of their Chinese population into Singapore where they created their own state.

Ethnic harmony still doesn't exist in Indonesia where they slaughtered Chinese back in the day and currently slaughter Christians when the opportunity presents itself.

Brunei on the other hand is a speck of a nation with oil wealth. Perhaps they are stable, I don't know.

If they are harmonious its because they slaughtered big and early.
Posted by: rjschwarz   2012-04-26 08:49  

00:00