You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
China-Japan-Koreas
Carter accuses S.Korea, US of withholding food from N.Korea
2011-04-30
Former U.S. President Jimmy Carter
... the worst president ever. Maybe the second worst. The votes aren't all in yet...
on Thursday urged the West not to interfere over human rights
...which are usually open to widely divergent definitions...
in North Korea and immediately resume food aid to the renegade nation. Carter was in Seoul as part of a group of ex- leaders calling themselves the "Elders" that included former Irish President Mary Robinson and former Finnish President Martti Ahtisaari who were winding up a three-day visit to North Korea.

Carter, 86, who was not travelling on behalf of the U.S. government, had been invited to North Korea for discussions with senior political and military officials as a way to ease tensions on the Korean Peninsula, which he said were ''at rock bottom."

He travelled with two other former presidents, Mary Robinson of Ireland and Martti Ahtisaari of Finland, and former prime minister Gro Harlem Brundtland of Norway. All four are members of the Elders, an independent group of world leaders established by Nelson Mandela.

Ms Robinson echoed Carter's concerns about what she called the "very serious crisis" over food supplies in North Korea because of a harsh winter, severe flooding and an outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease. She said the withdrawal of U.S. and South Korean food shipments had aggravated a dire situation, which had become "a matter of life-and-death urgency."

Ms Brundtland cited a lack of running water in hospitals, even in maternity and pediatric wards, and a deep shortage of what she called "essential medicines." A third of all North Korean children were stunted because of malnourishment, she said.

Carter said North Korean Vice Foreign Minister Ri Yong-ho came to the guest house, where he took a sheet of paper from an envelope and read to them what he said was a written message from Kim.

"He specifically told us that he is prepared for a summit meeting directly with President Lee Myung-bak at any time to discuss any subject directly between the two heads of state," Carter said.

Kim Jong-il "sent word that he and the people of North Korea are willing to negotiate with South Korea or the United States or (the other powers involved in six-party nuclear disarmament talks) on any subject, at any time and without any preconditions," he added.

Asked if he mentioned human rights to North Korean officials, Carter said he believes there are some human rights concerns about the North Korean regime's policies but that they cannot be changed by outsiders.

He said that one of the most important human rights is "to have food to eat and for South Korea and Americans, and others to deliberately withhold food aid for North Korean people... is indeed a human rights violation." Critics in South Korea were stunned that Carter appeared to ignore the Kim Jong-il regime's responsibility for egregious violation of human rights including the operation of concentration camps, public executions and torture but accused Seoul of violating North Korean rights.
Posted by:Fred

#17  " I guess the current President has been sinking so fast, that Jimmy needed to do something to stay at the bottom."

* snort *

P2k takes the lead for Snark O' the Day™.

By the way, you owe me a new monitor, P.
Posted by: Barbara Skolaut   2011-04-30 16:37  

#16  I guess the current President has been sinking so fast, that Jimmy needed to do something to stay at the bottom.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2011-04-30 16:27  

#15  I think that's it RJ, a volunteer human-shield and/or hostage. Someone quipped (I wish I could give proper credit) the other day that NORK holds its people hostage so the west either lets millions starve or feeds/arms their declared mortal enemy.
Posted by: swksvolFF   2011-04-30 16:23  

#14  enablers generally have a sick sense of love and support, so...
I would say "spot on", Al-Aska Paul
Posted by: Frank G   2011-04-30 15:34  

#13  The Kimmie regime in NORK has remained while others fell because of governments giving so-called humanitarian aid that propped up said regime. Including the US. Jimmy and Co are enablers of despots, not humanitarians.
Posted by: Alaska Paul   2011-04-30 14:41  

#12  Kim Jong-il "sent word that he and the people of North Korea are willing to negotiate with South Korea or the United States or (the other powers involved in six-party nuclear disarmament talks) on any subject, at any time and without any preconditions," he added.

What's to negotiate? Drop your guns and come out with your hands up or stay in there and starve.
Posted by: Abu Uluque   2011-04-30 13:41  

#11  If James Earl Carter looked me dead in the eye and said the grass was green and the sky is blue, I'd take a trusted team of people outside to confirm it.

Mike
Posted by: Mike Kozlowski   2011-04-30 13:27  

#10  "Carter, 86, who was not travelling on behalf of the U.S. government, had been invited to North Korea for discussions with senior political and military officials as a way to ease tensions on the Korean Peninsula, which he said were ''at rock bottom." "

Well no problem. If tensions were high that would be bad, but tensions at rock bottom sounds like the peninsula is happy for a change. No wonder the North wants Carter there.

I suspect the oddly worded bit is more the fault of the writer than Carter but I think its funny.
Posted by: rjschwarz   2011-04-30 10:45  

#9  He's Invited to Nork?
We'll be paying ransom to get him back.
So why go? Or is that the whole idea, Go and let them ransom him back?
Posted by: Redneck Jim   2011-04-30 10:27  

#8  would someone do me a favour and shoot Jimmah in the head ?
so much stuipidity in one man is unbelievable.
Posted by: Elder of Zion   2011-04-30 10:22  

#7  I've always said him and Obumbles have the same smile. Two america-hating individuals.
Posted by: CrazyFool   2011-04-30 10:03  

#6  How Carter rose from an inept dogcatcher intern to POTUS is the feat of the 20th Century.
Posted by: jack salami   2011-04-30 09:59  

#5  I wonder how long a starving cripple would be able to attack anyone.

I think the scenario has been covered in a couple hundred zombie movies and games. Just don't let them get too close to mob you.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2011-04-30 09:04  

#4  I wonder how long a starving cripple would be able to attack anyone.It might be unpleasant, perhaps even "disturbing" to be attacked by a starving cripple....but, ask yourself, just how long would the attack last...and who would ultimately win?

That is the bottom line...who is going to win. Club him when he comes and then get him in the bag. You can always wash up afterwards. Have a special unit ready for Kimmie, say he was killed in the fighting and look sorry about it.

Load the cripple on the truck, move in your own Army and keep out the reporters. You can triage to your advantage, make sure the Chinese frontier is secured. Explore the potentialities of benign neglect and salvage the useful. There are a myriad of ways to control and isolate NGOs.
Give it three weeks for the whole world to forget, they always do.

Get on with it.
Posted by: de Medici3489   2011-04-30 07:53  

#3  TOPIX > COMMUNIST REBELS VOW TO RESIST RETURN OF US TO [former]PHILIPPINES BASES, in any shape, form, or size.

Methinks its safe to say that the MUSLIM REBELS will also resist.
Posted by: JosephMendiola   2011-04-30 01:30  

#2  On the surface it would appear that ex-POTUS Jimbo is going against the very same, original Human Rights-centric rationale he began his international sojourns long ago after he left office.

OTOH, METHINKS JIMBO RECOGNIZES THAT NORTH KOREA'S DOMESTIC SITUATION [Food] IS STEADILY EVOL BEYOND DIRE, + THAT NEW FULL-SCALE WAR ON THE KOREAN PENINSULA IS MUCH CLOSER THAN ANYONE WILL ADMIT. IMO Jimbo likely is seeing that the US-West + ROK + UNO may have no choice in the end but to prioritize INTER-KOREAN, REGIONAL PEACE OVER HUMAN RIGHTS ABUSES IN NORTH KOREA.

FOOD AID = STOPPING KIMMIE FROM ATTACKING VARIOUS MAJOR MIL TARGETS IN SOUTH KOREA + JAPAN, THUS ACHIEVING DPRK-DESIRED "MUTUAL DESTRUCTION" + INTENTIONAL US-CHINA, ETC. REGIONAL CONFLICT INCLUD NUCWAR???

Kimmie + Regime have no qualms about fighting the MAD "final battle" that Reagan, Bush 1 + Gorby did not after the collapse of the Berlin Wall + implosion of the USSR.

* WAFF > NORTH KOREA CONTINUING TO BUILD NUCLEAR REACTOR [Yongybon] | {StrategyPage] NORTH KOREA: THE ARABIAN NIGHTMARE.

* DEFENCE.PK/FORUMS > REAL POVERTY IN CHINA [PRC versus UNO WB Poverty Standards].

ARTIC = China continues to claim "neglible" poverty rates + 10% annual growth rates despite having Asia's, World's biggest population of poor.
Posted by: JosephMendiola   2011-04-30 00:41  

#1  But the Norks can afford to develop nuclear weapons and keep a HUGE standing army.

What a bunch of sick disgusting excuses for human beings.
Posted by: CrazyFool   2011-04-30 00:28  

00:00