You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Politix
DeMint: There Will Be No Bailout for the States
2011-01-20
Here's the question I put to Sen. Jim DeMint during a brief telephone interview last night:

Chances are pretty good that Illinois, California, and New Jersey, and maybe a dozen or more other states, are going to go broke -- because they cannot meet their pension expenses. All told, the states are about $3 trillion short, and they're going to come looking to Congress for a bailout. Are you going to write that check, or are you going to let them hang and watch the municipal-bond market collapse? Which angry mob do you want to face?

Senator DeMint did not exactly say, "We're going to let the municipal-bond market collapse," but it sure sounded a lot like that. Republicans have a three-part plan for the states' fiscal crises:

First, create a legal process to allow states to renegotiate debts and union contracts in something akin to bankruptcy.

Second, forbid a congressional bailout of the states.

Third, forbid the Fed to buy states' debt as part of a freelance Ben Bernanke bailout.

In other words, prepare a site for crash-landing state finances and then forcibly guide them to it.

That third part is interesting, no? Republicans are looking askew at the Fed's new career as at-large bailout-maker.

The Republicans' plan looks pretty ugly, but I do not see any plausible alternatives. And I see one big opportunity: This is the chance to pry the parasitic government-employee unions off the body politic. They have bankrupted the states, and the resulting crisis gives us the means and the opportunity to put an end to their plunder. When those contracts get renegotiated, Republicans should insist that they address more than pensions.
Interesting plan. A lot could go wrong, but we are really sailing into uncharted waters here with lots of states and the feds in bankruptcy territory. Decoupling the public unions from the state would go a long way to keep this debt bomb from happening again.
Posted by:DarthVader

#6  There is an old American saying, "You don't rob Peter to pay Paul." Everybody in that stae bites the bullet. The liberal eperiment failed (again). You are a man if you can dust yourself off, roll up your sleeves, and start over again.
Posted by: wr   2011-01-20 21:18  

#5  What real choice is there? The 15 states already headed for bankruptcy constitute a solid majority of state population. Since (by definition) THEIR population can't pay the bills, bailing them out would amount to the rest of the population - a minority - paying their bills (through the Federal government, with extra overhead fees extracted.) THAT would bankrupt the rest of the states, in the end.
I bet this is how the Mayan and Egyptian empires collapsed - too many well-paid public employees for the population to support.
Posted by: Glenmore   2011-01-20 19:44  

#4  And while the states go through this 'bankruptcy' process they should get demoted to territories - until they can clean their house - and prove it.

No, sorry, but you can't vote yourself a bailout with other people's money.
Posted by: CrazyFool   2011-01-20 16:53  

#3  Only bubbles collapse, and the muni-bond market is part of the credit bubble. It's best to stop bubbles forming by controlling credit volume (i.e high reserves), but if they exist letting them implode is safer than keeping the economically harmful malinvestment caused by excess credit.
Posted by: Bright Pebbles   2011-01-20 15:30  

#2  Only because they ran out of money bailing out the politically connected.
Posted by: Bright Pebbles   2011-01-20 15:27  

#1  "The RepublicansÂ’ plan looks pretty ugly, but I do not see any plausible alternatives."

-actually, what I think the states have done to themselves is pretty ugly. The Repubs' plan is sound (& pretty damn generous) considering the malfeasance of the state govt's of mexifornia & ILLinoise.
Posted by: Broadhead6   2011-01-20 14:23  

00:00