You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Olde Tyme Religion
Moderate Muslim Watch: Handy Quick Tools for Spotting the Frauds
2010-10-13
by Claire Berlinski
Lots of links embedded in the text at the link.
Having presented several examples of men and women who are genuine moderates, I now turn to the question apparently on everyone's mind: How do you tell the real moderates from the frauds?...

If you're serious about distinguishing real moderates from faux-moderates, however, here are two quick and easy ways to start. Look for Saudi financing, and look for connections to the Muslim Brotherhood. Both are apt to be opaque--sometimes not very opaque at all, but opaque enough that most people don't notice--and both should immediately raise your suspicions that you're not dealing with a moderate.

I'm going to start slowly with the list of American organizations that accept large donations from the Saudis and have close connections to the Brotherhood, because there are a lot, and I'm hoping these names really sink in. The Muslim Students Association was founded by the Brothers. The Council on American Islamic Relations--loads of well-documented Muslim Brotherhood ties. The Islamic Society of North America and Fiqh Council of North America (they're associated): pure Brotherhood goodness, enriched with nourishing Saudi vitamins.

This final observation would have some wry comic value if it weren't so unfunny. ISNA insists on its website that it has nothing to do with the Muslim Brotherhood and "does not accept funding from foreign governments."

On the very same site, it announces the HRH Prince Alwaleed bin Talal ISNA Fellowship program.

I suppose they think most people won't notice that. Alas, they're right.

From the comment thread, about how to find the ones who're faking moderation while taking money from from the Magic Kingdom or are connected to the Brotherhood:
But if you've got access to Google and you're aware that the first words to look for are Saudi financing and the words "Muslim Brotherhood," you can rule people and groups out of the category "moderate" pretty quickly. Most of this stuff is no secret at all--people just don't realize that it should ring alarm bells.
I've cut this down for copyright reasons. The entire article, at the link, is very informative -- and entertaining.
Posted by:

#2  "For me, a good (but not perfect) filter would be outrage at Muslim outrages"

A better one would be the same but in Arabic for an Arabic audience. Saying/lying to the Christians doesn't really prove much.
Posted by: rjschwarz   2010-10-13 15:39  

#1  f you're serious about distinguishing real moderates from faux-moderates, however, here are two quick and easy ways to start. Look for Saudi financing, and look for connections to the Muslim Brotherhood. Both are apt to be opaque--sometimes not very opaque at all, but opaque enough that most people don't notice--and both should immediately raise your suspicions that you're not dealing with a moderate.

The emphasis obviously is on "start", as in being a good first-cut approximation that filters out most of the heavy hitters. Obviously won't work for individuals working on their own or being funded by the likes of Al Quada.

For me, a good (but not perfect) filter would be outrage at Muslim outrages: Comment #4 at this post provides excellent test material. Don't use one or two, but hit the test subject with the whole nasty mess and see how they react.
Posted by: Ptah   2010-10-13 13:16  

00:00