You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Afghanistan
McChrystal's real offense
2010-06-22

There is a lot of uproar about Gen. Stanley's McChrystal's disrespectful comments about his civilian bosses in the Obama administration, and President Obama would be entirely justified in firing McChrystal for statements McChrystal and his subordinates made to Rolling Stone. Obama is a deeply flawed commander-in-chief who doesn't want to be fighting a war on terror, but he is the commander-in-chief. He should have a general who will carry out his policies without public complaint until the voters can decide to change those policies.

But the bigger problem with McChrystal's leadership has always been the general's devotion to unreasonably restrictive rules of engagement that are resulting in the unnecessary deaths of American and coalition forces. We have had many, many accounts of the rules endangering Americans, and the Rolling Stone article provides more evidence. In the story, a soldier at Combat Outpost JFM who had earlier met with McChrystal was killed in a house that American officers had asked permission to destroy. From the article:

The night before the general is scheduled to visit Sgt. Arroyo's platoon for the memorial, I arrive at Combat Outpost JFM to speak with the soldiers he had gone on patrol with. JFM is a small encampment, ringed by high blast walls and guard towers. Almost all of the soldiers here have been on repeated combat tours in both Iraq and Afghanistan, and have seen some of the worst fighting of both wars. But they are especially angered by Ingram's death. His commanders had repeatedly requested permission to tear down the house where Ingram was killed, noting that it was often used as a combat position by the Taliban. But due to McChrystal's new restrictions to avoid upsetting civilians, the request had been denied. “These were abandoned houses,' fumes Staff Sgt. Kennith Hicks. “Nobody was coming back to live in them.'

One soldier shows me the list of new regulations the platoon was given. “Patrol only in areas that you are reasonably certain that you will not have to defend yourselves with lethal force,' the laminated card reads. For a soldier who has traveled halfway around the world to fight, that's like telling a cop he should only patrol in areas where he knows he won't have to make arrests. “Does that make any f–king sense?' Pfc. Jared Pautsch. “We should just drop a f–king bomb on this place. You sit and ask yourself: What are we doing here?'
Posted by:GolfBravoUSMC

#5  Joe.....
Not only do I fear that you are absolutely correct, but I also have a sinking feeling that we are ever accelerating toward that end.
I would like to suggest the term "GOAT-LIFT" vs 'CAMEL-LIFT may be a little more appropriate in your prediction.
Posted by: junkiron   2010-06-22 23:56  

#4  RADICLA ISLAM "COMING TO AMERICA", + by "Any + ALL Means Necessary", legal or illegal including HUmanitarian???
Posted by: JosephMendiola   2010-06-22 18:57  

#3  "[Combat Outpost] JFM is a small encampment" > so was BEECHER's ISLAND FIGHT, ADOBE WALLS, + many other sites of major battle.

So was R Lee Ermey's FIREBASE GLORIA flick.

IMO the core issue wid GEN. MCCHRYSTAL is broadly that once US = US-NATO withdrawal formally begins in 2011, EVERYONE KNOWS THE MILITANT GROUPS WILL LIKELY ATTEMPT A RETURN TO VIOLENT INSURGENCY, where the US GOVT-DOD + ALLIED is uncertain of the final outcome.

Its 1973 - Ala WATERGATE the US has signed a peace deal wid NVN whereupon the bulk of NVA + VC forces is left in-place throughout SVN, soon to become NIXON RESIGNATION, Year 1975 + FALL OF SAIGON,SVN PART II???

* POST-SAIGON VIETNAMESE, etc. BOATLIFTS = POST-2012 "GREAT AFGHAN/AFPAK CAMEL-LIFT" + Boatlift to GUAM [now also CNMI, etc.]again???

CONGESTED GUAM-CNMI > MUSLIM, etc. REFUGEES + 2014 MARINES RELOC FROM OKINAWA???
Posted by: JosephMendiola   2010-06-22 18:55  

#2  Having a Combat Outpost named for you is pretty impressive, JFM. Congrats.
Posted by: Glons Peacock4612   2010-06-22 12:50  

#1  McChrystal sounds like an Obama man all the way with his ROE.

Of course, we fought an entire war in Viet Nam with those kinds of crazy crap restrictions in place.

There are no civilians in an "asymmetrical" conflict. They either aid you or they aid the enemy and if they are in areas controlled by the bad guys, they are part of the problem.

Screw em all. If they are not actively fighting the Taliban, they are the Taliban.
Posted by: James Carville   2010-06-22 10:52  

00:00