You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
-Signs, Portents, and the Weather-
NZ sheep ranchers ordered to stop using sheepdogs
2009-04-08
It means shepherds at the farm may need to use methods such as beating the ground with sticks and waving their arms to control the flock.
Sheepdogs herding a flock may be a familiar farmyard scene, but it could soon be confined to the past if bosses at Tesco have their way. The supermarket chain has told its major supplier of lamb to stop using dogs, which it claims cause stress to the animals.

It means shepherds at the farm may need to use methods such as beating the ground with sticks and waving their arms to control the flock.
Wouldn't that also stress the sheep?
Outraged staff at Silver Fern Farms in Fairton, New Zealand may now have to get rid of up to 60 dogs to comply with the orders, meaning several of the animals will be destroyed. Shepherd Mick Pethram told the Telegraph newspaper: 'New Zealand sheep are used to dogs, they know dogs. There's more stress in a human herding and manhandling them, waving their arms and beating sticks. Dogs are part of a sheep's life. This is absolute baloney.'

He continued: 'We'll be desperately trying to sell them, but most of us will end up putting down three or four each. These are good dogs. Taking away our dogs is like taking a hammer away from a builder; we can't do our job without them.'

In New Zealand, abattoirs are attached to farms and dogs are usually used to herd the sheep before slaughter. Buyers for Tesco visited Silver Ferns Farm, which is one of the chain's biggest suppliers of lamb, earlier this year and were said to be upset at the dogs 'running riot'. A spokesperson for the store said: ' We don't have a problem with sheepdogs, but we need to make sure they treat the sheep in a considerate manner, so they don't stress the sheep out.'

Scientists have found evidence that causing stress to animals before slaughter can cause the meat to become pale and watery. However a spokesperson for the National Farmers Union said there was no evidence that sheepdogs caused animals to feel stressed.
Posted by:Seafarious

#9  However a spokesperson for the National Farmers Union said there was no evidence that sheepdogs caused animals to feel stressed.

Maybe some of the Tesco buyers can talk to the sheep and find out if that's really true.
This is baaaad...
Posted by: tu3031   2009-04-08 15:41  

#8   The West is rapidly committing cultural suicide.

It is a sad day for Western Civilization when a nation of sheep botherers loses the collective will to bother sheep.
Posted by: SteveS   2009-04-08 15:24  

#7  Yeah, the stress diagnosis sounds like a recommendation from a Muslim scientist based on ulterior motives.
Posted by: Galactic Coordinator Omavising9607   2009-04-08 15:09  

#6  Tesco was bloody quick to pull all the danish products off its shelves during the Motoons boycott.
Posted by: Seafarious   2009-04-08 10:46  

#5  I believe New Zealand and Australia are leading suppliers of mutton to Saudi and other ME markets. Sounds like the Muzzies are 'offended' again and supermarket is bowing to Muslims.
Posted by: Thealing Borgia 122   2009-04-08 10:40  

#4  The West is rapidly committing cultural suicide.
Posted by: lotp   2009-04-08 08:41  

#3  ' We don't have a problem with sheepdogs, but we need to make sure they treat the sheep in a considerate manner, so they don't stress the sheep out.'

Anthropomorphic twits.

Anyone who has ever been around sheep and watched a good sheepdog (a thing of beauty in itself) trying to do its duties knows why it 'runs riot' when trying to control them. Domestic sheep are pretty stupid, 'stressed out' most of the time anyway and don't follow human orders well (even beating the ground with sticks would only cause them to look at you once or twice and go back to grazing). You need to push, shove, drag or 'nip' them to get them to go in a predetermined direction.

My great uncle (who kept a few) told me that the domestic sheep would be one of the first animals to die off if humans ever became extinct as they are pretty incapable of fending for themselves, other than eating whatever is around them.
Posted by: Mullah Richard   2009-04-08 08:09  

#2  The supermarket chain has told its major supplier of lamb to stop using dogs, which it claims cause stress to the animals.

Eating them puts a lot of stress on them too, fool.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2009-04-08 08:05  

#1  They tried using muslims but it made the sheep way too nervous.
Posted by: ed   2009-04-08 01:27  

00:00