You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Iraq
What If Iraq Works?
2008-07-31
There is a growing confidence among officers, diplomats, and politicians that a constitutional Iraq is going to make it. We don't hear much anymore of trisecting the country, much less pulling all American troops out in defeat.

Critics of the war now argue that a victory in Iraq was not worth the costs, not that victory was always impossible. The worst terrorist leaders, like Abu Musab al-Zarqawi and Muqtada al-Sadr, are either dead or in hiding.

The 2007 surge, the Anbar Awakening of tribal sheiks against al-Qaeda, the change to counterinsurgency tactics, the vast increase in the size and competence of the Iraqi Security Forces, the sheer number of enemy jihadists killed between 2003 and 2008, the unexpected political savvy of Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki, and the magnetic leadership of Gen. David Petraeus have all contributed to a radically improved Iraq.
Posted by:GolfBravoUSMC

#11  Not as big a problem as the mullahs in Iran and the royals in Saooooodi.
Posted by: remoteman   2008-07-31 20:03  

#10  If Iraq works (which it seems to be), the Donks and their co-conspirators, the MSM will have problems with it.
Posted by: JohnQC   2008-07-31 18:29  

#9  I am hoping it works.

I'm thinking I may immigrate there when I retire.

I kind of cotton to the idea of spending my Golden Years in a free country.
Posted by: Kelly   2008-07-31 16:04  

#8  I agree but that role model thing won't last after we've moved on to bases or out of Iraq entirely. Much better to have Uncle Abdul move back into the old neighborhood and bore the folks about how in America we did it this way and it worked pretty well...
Posted by: rjschwarz   2008-07-31 12:50  

#7  Do keep in mind, the relationships between our GI's and the Iraqi kids.... Role models? The best in the world.
Posted by: Sherry   2008-07-31 12:29  

#6  It would be nice if Iraqi's from around the world (I know we have a ton down here in San Diego) would return to Iraq with their years of living in a peaceful, civilized, democracy. That learning experience has to be valuable to the new Iraqi democracy.
Posted by: rjschwarz   2008-07-31 11:29  

#5  Flying pigs
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2008-07-31 10:33  

#4  VDH is SUCH a good writer!
Posted by: Bugs Elmomomp6649   2008-07-31 10:02  

#3  We still have troops billeted in Germany, Japan and South Korea, Jack. So, too, should we keep American troops in Iraq for several generations. Not to mention that the rest of the region remains at a slow boil, making it likely we'll want to have units readily available for whatever the next step in the War on Terror needs to be.
Posted by: trailing wife    2008-07-31 09:54  

#2  They've jsut had a population blood transfusion. We killed piles of the ones that needed to be expelled fromt he "bloodstream", and that serves as a vacciene.

The error you make is believing that we are goign to be completely gone quickly. Not so, We will likely have 50K toops there for a decade or more. And as their military gets stronger it will be a bulwark for society against the abuses of the Islamists and any would-be dictators.


Posted by: OldSpook   2008-07-31 09:42  

#1  Only with a generational - all encompassing - population blood transfusion will it ever work. They just do not have the history or backboard to serve against. Once we are gone and they are the lone "democracy" in that world, how long do you think it will last?
Posted by: Jack is Back!   2008-07-31 08:27  

00:00