You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Britain
Sharia row persists for Williams
2008-02-11
Dr Rowan Williams is still caught in the eye of the Sharia law storm. The Archbishop of Canterbury is facing criticism from fellow Anglicans over his comments on Islamic Sharia law. He has provoked condemnation from the Anglican Archbishop in Latin America, who said confidence in Dr Rowan Williams's leadership had plummeted.
Archbishop Venables is an orthodox Christian who has given a church home to traditional Episcopalian parishes and dioceses who can no longer stand the idiocy in ECUSA. I'm pretty sure he knows exactly what the Islamicist threat is in Latin America ... moreover he has been increasingly critical of the failure to lead coming out of Canterbury under the Druid.
Dr Williams's predecessor Lord Carey has also weighed into the row saying the acceptance of some Muslim laws would be "disastrous" for Britain.

Supporters of Dr Williams say reaction to his comments has been "hysterical".

On Monday, he will face the Anglican Church's national assembly - the General Synod - when it gathers for the body's biannual meeting. There is a chance a motion could be tabled to discuss the issue. Dr Williams has insisted he was not advocating a parallel set of laws but has faced calls for his resignation.

BBC News religious affairs correspondent Robert Pigott said it was "inconceivable" that Dr Williams would be forced to quit, adding the Archbishop was held in "deep affection and respect" by rank and file Anglicans. He said the long-term problems might lie abroad in the Anglican communion. "The international church is already deeply split over the issue of homosexuality," he said. "Many Anglicans in Africa and Asia live side-by-side with Muslims and for them Sharia is a sensitive issue. Dr Williams's remarks have damaged his personal authority."

The Most Reverend Gregory Venables, Archbishop of Latin America, said his comments were a "surprise". "Taken within the context of other things that have been said and done in recent months, it will just add to the general sense that confidence in the leadership of the Anglican Church has plummeted," he said.

Confidence in Dr Williams has also been eroded at home, with criticism from the church's former leader Lord Carey. He flatly contradicted the Archbishop's suggestion that the law should incorporate elements of Sharia. But writing in the News of the World, Lord Carey said he should not be forced to quit.

Alun Michael, former Home Office minister, accused Dr Carey of being "disloyal" and condemned what he called the "absurd media feeding frenzy". He told BBC Wales' Politics Show: "If the reportage in the press is hysterical, inaccurate and inflammatory then it's very difficult for those who are asked to comment on it to deal with it properly."

Since making the remarks in a lecture to lawyers and in the BBC interview, Dr Williams has produced both anger and agreement from politicians, religious leaders, the public and people within his own church. At least two General Synod members have called on him to resign.

Catholic leader Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O'Connor is one of the many to come out in defence of Dr Williams. "I feel he may fear that people with a Christian conscience will be put to the sidelines and not allowed to say what they believe to be true for the common good," he told the BBC.
Posted by:lotp

#5  I'll bet that's an interesting job. I also notice he's based out of Abu Dhabi. Wouldn't wanna take the Magic outta the Magic Kingdom...
Posted by: tu3031   2008-02-11 21:48  

#4  There is a Bishop of Arabia.

But your point is noted.
Posted by: Pappy   2008-02-11 21:40  

#3  I wonder what the Archbishop of Riyadh has to say about this? Oh...that's right...
Posted by: tu3031   2008-02-11 13:30  

#2  Whatis being advocated here is allowing muslims in the UK to choose to handle legal issues under sharia rather than under UK law.

It's still stupid, stupid, stupid. But it doesn't mean that those with a 'christian conscience' will be subject to it.

Yet.
Posted by: Pappy   2008-02-11 13:28  

#1  Catholic leader Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O'Connor is one of the many to come out in defence of Dr Williams. "I feel he may fear that people with a Christian conscience will be put to the sidelines and not allowed to say what they believe to be true for the common good," he told the BBC.

What does the Cardinal think will happen to people with a Christian conscience under Sharia law? The usual result is the men are killed, the women raped, the homes burned, and the businesses looted. Stupid! Stupid! Stupid!
Posted by: RWV   2008-02-11 10:15  

00:00