You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Afghanistan
West wonÂ’t win Afghan war: ex-UN envoy
2007-10-18
BRUSSELS - International forces are unlikely to win their battle against the Taliban in Afghanistan, risking a regional conflict that could match the magnitude of previous world wars, a former top U.N. envoy said on Wednesday.

Lord Paddy Ashdown -- former United Nations high representative and European Union special representative for Bosnia and Herzegovina -- said failure by the NATO-led force would have far wider repercussions than any losses in Iraq. He called for the appointment of a high-level coordinator to lead the foreign mission in Afghanistan.
Himself, of course, though he denies lusting for the job.
“I think we are losing in Afghanistan now, we have lost I think and success is now unlikely,” he told Reuters in an interview. “I believe losing in Afghanistan is worse than losing in Iraq. It will mean that Pakistan will fall and it will have serious implications internally for the security of our own countries and will instigate a wider Shiite, Sunni regional war on a grand scale.”
If indeed we were losing in Afghanistan it would indeed put pressure on the Paks, though the Paks are liable to go down anyways. But the notion that a terrorist group that has the support of a minority of the population is going to defeat the West is silly -- it happens only if we lose our nerve. Which Mr. Ashdown has already lost.
“Some people refer to the First and Second World Wars as European civil wars and I think a similar regional civil war could be initiated by this (failure) to match this magnitude,” Ashdown added.

The number of Taliban suicide attacks in Afghanistan -- more than 100 so far this year -- is set to top last yearÂ’s record of 123, the United Nations says, and most victims are civilians.
In a country of 25 million people, these are pinpricks: irritating and a little unnerving, but not a cause for surrender. Particularly in the Tajik and Uzbek regions and in the West around Herat, there's virtually no booms and no fighting. Those folks, sensible ones, are working on reconstruction and have the usual gripes about government and corruption. It's the Pashtun area, from Afghanistan to the Pak frontier and tribal areas, that is the problem. That wall Fred wanted to build is looking better and better ...
The Taliban have increased the number of suicide attacks after suffering heavy casualties in conventional clashes with foreign forces and the Afghan army, security analysts say.
Cause and effect, though Mr. Ashdown can't see it.
While Western forces, alongside the Afghan army, have claimed victories against Taliban rebels in the south, many remote areas and some towns remain under rebel control and insurgent attacks have also spread north to regions previously considered safe. Frustration with the government over the slow pace of development, official corruption and the lack of law and order have all played into rebel hands.

Ashdown, a former British Liberal Party leader, said there was a “desperate need for somebody to coordinate the international efforts” and called for the appointment of someone to lead the foreign mission in Afghanistan. “Unless somebody has the power genuinely to coordinate and unify the international approach, we will lose and I think that is happening,” he said.

“It’s not about who does the job unless it's me, but what is the job and if the international community has the will to put together a post which has the authority, including the Americans, then they must do it now if they are to stand any chance.”

But Ashdown, who now heads the Brussels-based EU-Russia Centre think tank, had been tipped in some circles for such a role, but ruled himself out of the job. “I never talk about approaches, but what I will say is that I have had many high-level jobs and I am not looking for any big jobs at the moment. I am happy doing what I am doing with Russia,” he said.
He'd never do the job, unless he was asked ...
Posted by:Steve White

#12  All those in favor of trusting a Dhimmi with a gay name like Paddy,,,
Posted by: Icerigger   2007-10-18 17:23  

#11  " Imagine, if you can, a world wherein the top "international" posts are filled by intelligent, sane, morally unconfused people. "

It's not hard, the world of most novels and movies are filled with these types of people.
Posted by: rjschwarz   2007-10-18 17:06  

#10  Imagine, if you can, a world wherein the top "international" posts are filled by intelligent, sane, morally unconfused people.

I know, it's hard.

Only the spectacular success of free markets, open political systems, and the valor and skill of the armed forces of free countries has made a world possible in which we have this endless, infuriating supply of worthless nitwits like Ashdown. Enough already.
Posted by: Verlaine   2007-10-18 13:43  

#9  To paraphrase a certain Roman, "We can make a solitude & call it victory".
Posted by: gromgoru   2007-10-18 10:49  

#8  Â“Some people refer to the First and Second World Wars as European civil wars and I think a similar regional civil war could be initiated by this (failure) to match this magnitude,” Ashdown added.

Really? Who might those "some people" be?
UN, EU, Brussels think tank. There's a friggin hat trick.

Posted by: tu3031   2007-10-18 10:47  

#7  Not a word about the Dread Afghan Winter?
Posted by: SteveS   2007-10-18 09:57  

#6  I suppose we can file this with the 'Dire Warning'[tm] issued by 'experts' who predicted mass starvation if the US invaded Afghanistan to being with.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2007-10-18 08:57  

#5  I seem to remember exactly the same talk immediately before the USAF, US special forces and a bunch of guys on horseback drove out the dreaded Talibunnies in, what, four weeks? Kipling take note.
Posted by: Excalibur   2007-10-18 08:56  

#4  Paddy Ashdown was the titular head of the Liberal Party in the UK for many years. And one might say that he is an expert on failure, having dragged the party down on many an election night. However, I say he's a leftist on a par with the defeatocrat-appeasing 'RATs in this country.

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

Posted by: Galactic Coordinator Shins1195   2007-10-18 07:47  

#3  If we armed the Tadjiks and Uzbeks to wipe out the Pashtoons and carry off their women, would that be considered a win? Or would that be too ethnic for Lord Paddy?
Posted by: ed   2007-10-18 07:22  

#2  ION, as per IRAN, FREEREPUBLIC > WHAT IRAN HAS TO FEAR IF HILLARY WINS THE PRESIDENCY. Hillary is the one that said "all options are on the table" and that if need be, she will "bomb Iran". WND.com > HUCKABEE > WAR ON TERROR CAN NOT + WILL NOT END IN A DRAW. IOW, USA + Amer Way wins, or it dies. LUCIANNE > A CLINTON TO REBUILD THE MILITARY. POTUS Bill killed it, POTUS Hillary may build it back up. Finally, also from LUCIANNE > JOHN KERRY'S TIME MAY HAVE COME AGAIN. The GOP has McCain and Ron Paul, the Dems KERRY and the GOREACLE, and thats not counting the Babe Wars [ THE GIRL FACTOR/GIRL WARS/GIRL FACTOR articles]. NO WORD YET ON THE STATUS OF EDWARDS aka so-called "SILKY/BRECK GIRL"???
Posted by: JosephMendiola   2007-10-18 02:54  

#1  Thanks to Ashdown, Bosnia has a 43.7% unemployment rate. I think we need this guy to do for Afghanistan what he has done for Bosnia. Not.
Posted by: Zhang Fei   2007-10-18 00:14  

00:00