You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Southeast Asia
Burma general 'sacked for being too moderate'
2007-10-03
The Burmese general responsible for the city of Rangoon was sacked yesterday, suggesting that last week's popular uprising may have exposed divisions in the military.
Problem is, the people haven't yet suffered enough to be enraged enough to knock the generals aside.
According to the Mizzima website, run by Burmese exiles, Maj Gen Hla Htay Win was "allowed to retire" yesterday, allegedly for being too moderate in crushing the protests. He had supervised lethal dawn raids on monasteries and arrested many hundred monks and protesters. His men fired automatic weapons into crowds of unarmed civilians, killing an unknown number of people.

A Western diplomat said that Senior General Than Shwe, who controls the junta, favoured crushing the protests with even more extreme violence. Hla Htay Win is seen as a loyalist of Than Shwe's deputy and potential rival, Vice Senior General Mg Aye.

Mg Aye is sometimes portrayed as a moderate, although in the context of the Burmese junta that is a relative term which does not imply moderation as most people understand it.
There's a nice understatement.
At the height of the government's brutal crackdown last week there were widespread rumours that some troops in Rangoon had refused orders to fire on unarmed protesters. Rumours also suggest that Than Shwe was sufficiently worried as the street protests grew to send his family to safety in Dubai.

America yesterday accused Than Shwe of personally ordering the crackdown. "The stories are that he is isolated and that his staff are afraid to give him bad news but we do believe that he is the one to give the orders to crack down, so he is not totally out of touch," said Shari Villarosa, the US charge d'affaires in Rangoon.

Meanwhile fears mounted for the wellbeing of an estimated 1,500 people who were taken away by the army in the city last week. The Asian Human Rights Commission said that they "must all be treated as disappeared, not arrested, until their whereabouts and conditions are confirmed".

Some accounts say that they are being starved and that prisoners have died of untreated injuries. Miss Villarosa said that she had heard that up to 200 people had been killed during the protests and thousands had been arrested. "We have had people going around various monasteries and they have found them deserted," she said.

The junta is now confident enough that the protests have been crushed to remove the barbed wire and security cordons around the Shwedagon Pagoda, the starting place of daily demonstrations last week.
Posted by:Steve White

#2  More plainly, "Do away with others before they do away with you."
Posted by: Anguper Hupomosing9418   2007-10-03 21:10  

#1  This is why the pin-stripe and academically challenged can't fathom that in Iran, there is not going to be an effective popular uprising to remove those who control the reigns of power. As long as they have enough people willing to pull the triggers, the only change will happen from external forces. Hope is not a strategy. The mullahs, like these 'generals', know that if they lose power, they lose their heads. It's the golden rule of dictators, 'Do on to others, before they do on to you'.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2007-10-03 09:47  

00:00