You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Culture Wars
Murtha's Malicious Misinformation May Mean Mega-Misery
2007-08-29

A Christian law firm hopes that once its client is cleared of charges in connection with the so-called Haditha massacre, it will consider legal action against one of the men responsible for the accusations: Pennsylvania Congressman John Murtha. The Michigan-based Thomas More Law Center is representing Lt. Col. Jeffrey Chessani (USMC), who has been charged with not fully investigating the events at Haditha, Iraq, and failing to report a Law of War violation, in the aftermath of the November 19, 2005, incident that led to the death of 24 Iraqi civilians. Spokespersons for the legal group hope the convening officer in the investigation will throw out the charges as he already has for two of the six other men charged in the case. Chessani is the highest ranking officer charged in the case.

Congressman Murtha, a prominent war critic, last year accused U.S. Marines of shooting and killing unarmed civilians near the scene of an attack on a military convoy, then going into two homes and shooting others. According to Brian Rooney with the Law Center, Staff Sergeant Frank Wuterich -- one of the other defendants in the investigation -- is already suing Murtha for those comments. Rooney argues the Pennsylvania Democrat should be held accountable for taking the word of Iraqi insurgents and calling the Marines "cold-blooded murderers."

"Staff Sergeant Wuterich's attorneys are suing Congressman Murtha for liable for saying that the Marines were cold-blooded murderers, so that suit's still ongoing," the attorney explains, adding that the Law Center is considering taking similar action. "We're exploring our options ... in that regard because Murtha said that officers covered this up, which is explicitly naming our client as covering it up," says Rooney. "So once we get through with this court-martial -- and hopefully it goes our way -- then we're going to look at whether or not we should take a hard look at Congressman Murtha as well."

In comments during a June 2006 interview with ABC's Charles Gibson, Murtha stated, after a meeting with high-level Marines: "I know there was a cover-up someplace. They knew about this a few days afterwards, and there's no question the chain of command tried to stifle the story."
Usually someone making these sort of serious accusations has at least a shred of evidence. Allegations are not proof of anything.
Rooney says perhaps the people of Murtha's heavily Democratic district will vote him out of office next year. "Even if it's a Democratic district," he suggests, "you would hope that a Democrat of good conscience would stand up [against] what this congressman has put these men through."
Expect to see some Olympic Medal level backpedaling from this rectal cavity. Allowing ideology to overcome the value of truth is a betrayal of ethics.
Posted by:Zenster

#25  Lee Harvey Oswald was also a 'former Marine', if I understood Pappy correctly on the proper vernacular. My son, in that case, is an 'ex-Marine"?

No, Bobby, your son is a Marine, always will be. There are no former Marines, there are a few ex-marines. The Green doesn't always take.


Posted by: Thomas Woof   2007-08-29 17:22  

#24  Thanks PT.
Posted by: Jan    2007-08-29 16:51  

#23  Former Marines no longer waer the uniform.

Ex-Marines are few - that Murtha, and Scott Ritter (You remember him, the paedophile, weapons inspector)
Posted by: OldSpook   2007-08-29 14:16  

#22  Jan, News Max has a Haditha fund...100% goes to the defense fund.
Posted by: Phinater Thraviger   2007-08-29 14:14  

#21  Is there anyone collecting for the Marine to help financially in his defense? I would love to help with even the little I can give especially if he goes after Murtha.
Posted by: Jan    2007-08-29 14:03  

#20  Lee Harvey Oswald was also a 'former Marine', if I understood Pappy correctly on the proper vernacular. My son, in that case, is an 'ex-Marine"?

I get so confused ...
Posted by: Bobby   2007-08-29 13:51  

#19  I kniow soldiers fromt here - they say its like this: as long as the retired union leeches people get their checks, they'll pull the lever for Jack. The only thing that will get him run out of office is the proverbial being found in bed with a a dead woman or a live boy.
Posted by: OldSpook   2007-08-29 13:50  

#18  I always understood that there is no such thing as an ex-Marine.

Maybe we need to make an exception in this case. Nudge. Nudge.
Posted by: Zenster   2007-08-29 13:15  

#17  My dad was a Marine. So was my father in law. But so was this guy and Ramsey Clark, so I guess there's bound to be a few defects in the system...
Posted by: tu3031   2007-08-29 13:04  

#16  Did John Murtha assume the worst of these marines because of his own behavior in Viet Nam? I know that he was a well-decorated marine there, but is it possible that he also did some very bad things? Even though I detest what he did to our troops, I don't want to swift boat him. Unless, of course, he did do some terrible things while a marine.
Posted by: Angusoth Jones3773   2007-08-29 12:54  

#15  As one who served in the Corps, I always understood that there is no such thing as an ex-Marine. That is, until Murtha came along.
Posted by: Cowboy is a compliment   2007-08-29 12:26  

#14  Welfare in any form. The more you subsidize something the more of it you get. The heroin of the political class. Its make the constituents feel good in the short run, but destroys the body and will in the long run.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2007-08-29 12:00  

#13  BTW, it's 60 years plus of voting for dems that made the Johnstown area the blighted mess it is, same for the Mon Valley here. And yet, the voters of these benighted areas vote again and again for more of the same, and they get more of it, although the don't "get it..."
Posted by: M. Murcek   2007-08-29 10:53  

#12  The idea of voting him out is nice, but I live in the district next door, and I can tell ya there is no chance. His constituents are like zombies, living in a shelled out land of shuttered factories. If it weren't for the pork jackie boy sends there, it would be well on the way to reverting to forest land...
Posted by: M. Murcek   2007-08-29 10:50  

#11  Murtha is a very well known a**hole on the Hill. He is arrogant, egomanical and in some ways senile in his stupidity. He is a crook, a shyster and one of the most blatantly corrupt politicians in DC. I don't think it will take much legal action to have him crawl back under his rock with an apology.
Posted by: Jack is Back!   2007-08-29 10:33  

#10  It's too late. Murtha has already done too much damage, all the fawktards in the international press just repeat "Haditha, Haditha" as some sort of established fact.
Posted by: Abdominal Snowman   2007-08-29 10:03  

#9  I wish Wuterich had waited after his hearing. I bet the Dems are now putting pressure on the Marines to indict Wuterich and get Murtha off the hook.
Posted by: ed   2007-08-29 09:43  

#8  Usually someone making these sort of serious accusations has at least a shred of evidence. Allegations are not proof of anything.

It's called "projection". The Donks have an entire playbook of McCarthyism tactics. They just believe they should have a monopoly on the methodology and object if anyone else in even the slightest should do something that gives a scent of it. Especially, if the 'others' actually have the documentation and evidence by the box full.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2007-08-29 09:15  

#7  His district votes him out, or I vote his district out. That POS.
Posted by: newc   2007-08-29 07:39  

#6  The money might be more productively spent in a primary campaign. Success in that would make the subsequent suit much easier to pursue but reduce the value. A real EMV problem.
Posted by: Nimble Spemble   2007-08-29 07:24  

#5  Murtha is a disgrace to Marines, veterans and even to congressmen. He needs to be put on trial. I hope those Marines milk him for all he is worth.
Posted by: DarthVader   2007-08-29 07:16  

#4  Anymouse - I share your sentiments and pride. My son was there in 2004-2005 and said he will never forget being there for the elections. Keep the cards, letters, and care packages flowing - some of the kids don't seem to have families, and my son shared a lot of his loot. Semper Fi!
Posted by: Bobby   2007-08-29 07:01  

#3  Usually someone making these sort of serious accusations has at least a shred of evidence. Allegations are not proof of anything.

Except in cases of BDS syndrome. And Mumra Murtha is a typhoid-mary of BDS.
Posted by: CrazyFool   2007-08-29 06:06  

#2  'mouse, please be so kind as to extend my personal gratitude to your child for serving in our nation's defense. Ordinary words are wholly inadequate to the task.
Posted by: Zenster   2007-08-29 04:02  

#1  As the father of a Marine who will deploy to Iraq shortly...I hope that sorry sack of $hit rots in H*ll for what he did to those men and The Corps.
Posted by: anymouse   2007-08-29 03:28  

00:00