You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Israel-Palestine-Jordan
Hopes for release of 'West Bank Mandela'
2007-04-09
Nice finger wag, Marwan. Very Clintonian.
By Tim Butcher in Ramallah
For many Palestinians Marwan Barghouti is a living saint, the only politician capable of leading his people out of decades of Israeli occupation and fratricidal bloodletting to nationhood.
It's like the dude is frickin' *Moses*, man, can you dig it? Maybe even more Moses than Moses.
To many Israelis he is a ruthless terrorist who is rightly languishing in jail for his role in the murder of five people during the second intifada. But this seemingly intractable contradiction must somehow be resolved after his name headed the list of hundreds of prisoners the Palestinian authorities want released in exchange for Cpl Gilad Shalit, the Israeli soldier captured last year. Mr Barghouti has been incommunicado since he was jailed in 2002. But with growing pressure on Israel to negotiate a deal before the June anniversary of Cpl Shalit's capture, Palestinian hopes are high that the man many call the "Palestinian Nelson Mandela" could soon be released.
"Many" call him a Mandela. Although the only person he quotes by name is the son:
His 21-year-old son, Qassam, was unexpectedly released two weeks ago, fuelling hopes that Israel may be preparing the way for the release of his 47-year-old father. In a brief interview with The Daily Telegraph, Qassam, who shared a cell with his father, gave a rare insight into the thinking of the man many Palestinians pin their hopes on. "The key thing to remember about my father is that he is a listener and a pragmatist," said Qassam, at his Ramallah home between celebrations to mark his release. The law student was picked up in February 2003 as he returned from university in Cairo, and held without charge under Israel's administrative detention procedures. "When I saw him in jail, I noticed that he did not just listen to his people from his own movement, Fatah. He listened to everyone and was respectful of their views even if they differed from his." On the key question of recognising Israel, Qassam said, his father had made up his mind. "He believes that what happened in 1948 is a part of history and we, as Palestinians, must now accept that there will always be an Israel," said the young man who has the same pudgy, whiskered face as his father.
Awwww... precocious li'l tyke, ain't he?
"The only solution for this conflict must be two states side by side, an Israeli state and a Palestinian state. You must remember that he has supported this pragmatic view for many years but the Israelis simply don't want to listen. They go on and on about Hamas but when you have a leader like my father who wants to talk about peace the Israelis are not interested. They are just not honest about peace: time after time they show they are not interested in ending this conflict."

A criminal court sentenced Barghouti to five life sentences in 2002 for involvement in the murder of four Israelis and a Greek monk.
And what's *that* go do with anything? It's not like he outed Valerie Plame or fired a few prosecutors...
For many Israelis, the idea of letting the elder Barghouti go free is anathema. Uri Ariel, an MP from the right wing National Union-National Religious Party, said: "If it's true that Barghouti will be released as part of the Shalit deal - and I hope it's not - and if anyone plans to release a murderer who received five life sentences in jail, this will be the government's final failure, and it should quit before going bankrupt."
Nice work, going to the right wing National Union-National Religious Party for a reaction quote. Very subtle, innit?
But only if he is released can Barghouti show if he truly is the West Bank Mandela.
Nice little editorial there in the last sentence. Hey Tim, how's your buddy Alan Johnston doing?
Posted by:Seafarious

#8  Phil,

Let's remember one thing. South African apartheid was immoral. The Israeli occupation and later separation from the Gaza and the West Bank are justified and morally right.
Posted by: Eric Jablow   2007-04-09 22:14  

#7  If you kill scum like this, there won't be any reason for the Paleos to kidnap Israelis in hope of a prisoner exchange. You also reduce your overhead and make room for more pieces of feces to occupy those cells - for a short time. It also sends a clear message that all life is sacred - except for those that wantonly take life. That's a lesson the US hasn't quite gotten yet.
Posted by: Old Patriot   2007-04-09 16:37  

#6  What, this guy found his humanity all of a sudden? Let him go and see how long it is before he loses it again.
Posted by: gorb   2007-04-09 14:54  

#5  Barghouti shouldn't be rotting in an Israeli jail; he should be rotting in an unmarked grave. He's a murdering bastard like most of the rest of the Paleos held in Israeli jails. The sooner Israel initiates the death penalty for these scumbags, the better. You did in Eichmann; these guys would do worse if they ever got the chance and have done as badly as they could manage. They deserve to die; it might teach the others a lesson and certainly couldn't make them hate you any worse.
Posted by: Mac   2007-04-09 06:04  

#4  A new contender for the Paleo throne---and the chance to split American support for Abbas. Lay in extra popcorn.
Posted by: gromgoru   2007-04-09 03:12  

#3  The Mandela comparison is apt. Mandela was an admitted terrorist bomber.

Otherwise, the comparison ends there. Fatah/Hamas aren't the South African Nationals.
Posted by: phil_b   2007-04-09 03:06  

#2  I think it's worth a gamble. There seems to be no one competent in all of Palestine. Let him give it a shot. He can't add to the level of violence. Most likely he'll get killed. If not, well he'll be in Gaza which is roomier than an Israeli jail, it just doesn't have the amenities.

Posted by: Penguin   2007-04-09 01:45  

#1  I've never been able to reconcile Israel's understandable and generally consistent realism in dealing with the sea of idiotic hostility that surrounds them with these prisoner exchanges.

Nice mark-up, Sea. Me wonders how widespread the opposition to such an insane move is. The words by the right-wing MK weren't particularly incendiary, considering that the subject is release of a convicted murderer and enemy of the state.
Posted by: Verlaine   2007-04-09 01:16  

00:00