You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Culture Wars
School renames Three Little Pigs to avoid offending Muslims
2007-03-16
Ha -- in being politically correct, these folks forgot, that dogs are considered unclean animals in Islam?.. so why change to "Three Little Puppies?"
The story of the Three Little Pigs' battle with the Big Bad Wolf has delighted children since it was written more than 150 years ago. But the tale highlighting the merits of hardwork and practicality has become the latest to fall victim to political correctness.

A junior school production of the children's story has been renamed the Three Little Puppies for fear of offending Muslims. Organisers of a children's music festival have altered the popular characters and lyrics because of the multi-cultural nature of the youngsters involved and their parents in the audience.

But yesterday Islamic leaders condemned the politically correct move as misguided and said decisions like this were turning Muslims into 'misfits' in society.

Children from Honley Church of England Junior School in Huddersfield, West Yorkshire, were due to perform in a reworking of the popular tale which features the three little pigs. The youngsters - aged from seven to 11 - were due to perform at Huddersfield Town Hall in June with 250 children from 63 schools singing along.

But organisers of the Kirklees Primary Music Festival decided to change the script to be 'sensitive' to Muslims at a recent committee meeting.

Committee member Gill Goodswen, head teacher of Stile Common Junior School, defending the move. She said: "We have to be sensitive if we want to be multi-cultural. It was felt it would be more responsible not to use the three little pigs.

"We feared that some Muslim children wouldn't sing along to the words about pigs,' she said. "We didn't want to take that risk. If changing a few words avoids offence then we will do so." She stressed the decision was not prompted by a complaint from any school.
She was a ninny all on her own.
But Shaykh Ibrahim Mogra from the Muslim Council of Britain branded the move 'bizarre'. He said: "The vast majority of Muslims have no problem whatsoever with the Three Little Pigs. It's always been the traditional way of telling the story and I don't see why that should be changed.

"There's an issue about the eating of pork, which is forbidden, but there is no prohibition about reading stories about pigs. This is an unnecessary step."

Other recent rows have involved 'Baa Baa Black Sheep' being changed to 'Baa Baa rainbow sheep' and Christmas events called 'winter' festivities. Mr Mogra said: "How far are we going to go? Are we going to change the seven dwarves because it's discriminatory towards people who are physically less able? Where do you draw the line?

"Every time we get these stories Muslims are seen more and more as misfits. We have to accept there's a predominant culture here."

His views were echoed locally in Huddersfield. Local councillor Terry Lyons added: "I can't believe that Muslims would be offended by this. This is pandering to a few extremists. People will take umbrage at this decision, making it easier for the BNP to recruit."

Mohammed Imran, of the Hanfia Mosque and Educational Institute said: "According to the Koran it's forbidden to eat pork or touch a pig, but there's no ruling about talking about them or singing about them."

Steve Price, head of Honley C of E school, said he had not played a part in the decision, but added: "We are part of the family of Kirklees schools. This family is set up to celebrate children's talents and I can well understand some head teachers being careful about not causing offence."
Posted by:Sherry

#18  "There's an issue about the eating of pork, which is forbidden, but there is no prohibition about reading stories about pigs.

"In fact we have lots of state issued textbooks that depict Jews and Americans as pigs. See? It's no problem for us at all."
Posted by: Zenster   2007-03-16 23:24  

#17  Islam really needs a single voice to stand up and say what the line is. Having a million mullahs with their own interpetations will lead to the world thinking their nuts.

That and the constant seething and blowing themselves up that is.
Posted by: rjschwarz   2007-03-16 17:35  

#16  I knew this was going on in the UK as soon as I saw the headline. What the hell is going on in that once-proud country? Has the common man/woman lost their mind and spine? Gill Goodswen should be pilloried and made publicly to look like the idiot she clearly is. She should also be fired for being, well, dumb.
Posted by: remoteman   2007-03-16 16:18  

#15  They can have my lard when they pry my cold, dead fingers from it.
Posted by: GORT   2007-03-16 15:03  

#14  I like JM's allusion to the "Three Billy Goats Gruff." Should be changed to the "Three Nanny Goats Rough."
Posted by: Alaska Paul   2007-03-16 15:02  

#13  Kind of like how muzzies arent allowed to DRINK alcohol, but somoli cab drivers are making a federal case over not wanting to pick up passengers with a bottle of wine in their luggage.
Posted by: bigjim-ky   2007-03-16 12:13  

#12  Brilliant!
Posted by: DarthVader   2007-03-16 11:07  

#11  Now it's going to be "Three Little Jews", and the wolf gets to eat them at the end.
Posted by: Anonymoose   2007-03-16 10:26  

#10  "School renames Three Little Pigs to avoid offending Muslims"

They're wasting their time.

The wanna-be jihadis offensive moslems are offended by everything, including infidels having the unmitigated gall to breathe.

The normal muslims (like Mr. Mogra, and friends of mine) think they're pandering, ignorant PC bigots nuts.

I, on the other hand, think these clowns are pandering, ignorant PC bigots who set lower standards for those lower than different from themselves because they all know "those people" can't live up to the same standards as white Westerners.

Pfui.
Posted by: Barbara Skolaut   2007-03-16 10:18  

#9  But Shaykh Ibrahim Mogra from the Muslim Council of Britain branded the move 'bizarre'. He said: "The vast majority of Muslims have no problem whatsoever with the Three Little Pigs. It's always been the traditional way of telling the story and I don't see why that should be changed.

"There's an issue about the eating of pork, which is forbidden, but there is no prohibition about reading stories about pigs. This is an unnecessary step."


This was my thought exactly. This isnt the muslims fault at all, but that of some silly school administrators.

Like the idiots who think that kashrut makes it illegal to play football (cause of the pigskin)

"Pigs are friends, not food"

BTW, Ive been in plenty of (non-jewish) stores that sold kosher items but not halal. Has to do with market demand, I suspect.


Posted by: liberalhawk   2007-03-16 09:26  

#8  I found halal hotdogs for the first at my grocers last night; they have never sold kosher. One more concession to the cultists...
Posted by: Excalibur   2007-03-16 09:01  

#7  "Shaykh Ibrahim Mogra from the Muslim Council of Britain branded the move 'bizarre'."

There really are sane Muslims! This pervasive Western fear of offending anyone offends ME - what are they going to do about THAT?
Posted by: Glenmore   2007-03-16 08:48  

#6  "There's an issue about the eating of pork, which is forbidden, but there is no prohibition about reading stories about pigs. This is an unnecessary step."

Wait. If you're just not allowed to eat pork then why are Muzzies bitching about selling pork?
Posted by: Rob Crawford   2007-03-16 07:15  

#5  Are you sure this wasn't originally published by scrappleface? Political Correctness creates situations so bizarre that they are indistinguishable from satire.
Posted by: Jegum the Great3985   2007-03-16 03:19  

#4  tu3031, brilliant! ROFL!

(presuming we are talking still about piggies)
Posted by: twobyfour   2007-03-16 02:06  

#3  Three Billy Goats Gruff???
Posted by: JosephMendiola   2007-03-16 00:48  

#2  Rename them Mohammed, Muhammed, and Mahammad.
Problem solved.
Posted by: tu3031   2007-03-16 00:39  

#1  News flash - they don't like dogs any better.

Morons.
Posted by: mojo   2007-03-16 00:38  

00:00