You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Fifth Column
Watada court-martial to start tomorrow
2007-02-04
WASHINGTON (AFP) - First Lieutenant Ehren Watada, the first US army officer to publicly refuse orders to go to Iraq, will go on trial in a court martial Monday at Fort Lewis, Washington, according to his supporters. Watada is being tried for his refusal in June 2006 to be deployed to Iraq on the grounds that he opposed the decision of President George W. Bush to launch the war.
Except weepy editorials in the NYT Tuesday. HuffPo will lash out at the military and Bush (of course). Keith Olbermann will refer to Watada as an 'authentic American hero'. Then he'll be convicted and forgotten, having served his purpose to them.
He is being charged under the Uniform Code of Military Justice with expressing contempt toward Bush, of conduct unbecoming an officer and a gentleman, and purposely missing his unit's deployment when it departed for the Middle East on June 22, 2006. The charges, which could earn him four years in a military prison, cite statements Watada made on June 6 defending his decision on the basis that Bush initiated an illegal and immoral war.

"I could never conceive of our leader betraying the trust we had in him. As I read about the level of deception the Bush administration used to initiate and process this war, I was shocked. I became ashamed of wearing the uniform. If the president can betray my trust, it's time for me to evaluate what he's telling me to do," Watada said, according to the court martial charge sheet.
Guilty as charged.
A group of supporters of Watada plan to hold a demonstration outside Fort Lewis in the northwestern state on Monday, as well as a protest in his support outside the White House in Washington, the US capital.

Watada joined the army in 2003 and was posted in South Korea until 2005, when he was transferred to Fort Lewis to prepare for deployment to Iraq.
Joined in 2003, did he? Had to know his turn in Iraq was coming.
Instead he requested to be transferred to another unit and proposed that he be deployed to Afghanistan. That was turned down. Since his arrest he has been assigned to an office job in Fort Lewis while awaiting his trial.

His case has garnered significant support in a nation that has turned sharply against the Iraq war. Mike Honda, a member of the US House of Representatives, told the San Francisco Chronicle newspaper last week that Watada volunteered for the military in the wake of the September 11, 2001, attacks "out of a desire to protect his family and compatriots." Noting Watada's "exemplary" service record, Honda defended his act: "Watada is not alone. Poll after poll points to an ever-rising tide of public opposition to President Bush's handling of the war in Iraq."
All of which is irrelevant. Lieutenants don't make policy.
In an interview on National Public Radio in January, Watada said he felt he had no choice but to refuse to go to Iraq. "When I saw there were no other alternatives, I believed that I needed to take this issue to the public arena and let the people know why soldiers were dying in Iraq."

But he said the court martial will avoid the issues his refusal was aimed at raising. "In this case, the judge has already predetermined that he will not allow any evidence or witnesses to testify that the war is illegal or immoral. He has already predetermined that the order (to deploy) is lawful and, in a sense by charging me with missing movement, they are skirting the issue of the legality of the order."
Because that's not the issue. You disobeyed an order and cast disrespect on your superiors. Enjoy your time in military prison.
Posted by:Anguper Hupomosing9418

#5  Last night's Seattle NBC news (10 o'clock) had a long story about his supporters building picket signs and standing ready to go. SInce they are closer than the NYT, we can expect the weeping to be louder and sooner.
Posted by: USN, ret.   2007-02-04 23:07  

#4  Actually, since exJAG hasn't reported in, LR there is a judge. He does the administration and technical stuff. Got to make sure all the right papers are processed correctly for any appeal. He rules on points of law. And referees the discussion among the legal types representing the government and the defendant. The judge also instructs the board as to procedures in appropriate parts of the trial. The board has powers to question the witnesses, usually checked by the judge for appropriateness. It can also call/re-call witnesses.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2007-02-04 21:14  

#3  Watada thought he was going to join the U.S. Army and do what? go to football games? shoot at the evil men of his choosing, after they fill out a questionaire and are certified as being evil? does he want every single superior officer to pass his morality test before a lock and load?
How many murders of vegetable buying women does hehave to see before he decides he would intervene to save them?
Posted by: whatadeal   2007-02-04 20:37  

#2  Judge? What "judge"? It will be a courts martial PANEL - composed of other Army Officers -a jury of his "peers". The panel reports to the courts martial convening authority - who will be a General Officer. The first time that a "judge" will be involved will be if a verdict is appealed.

I doubt that his peer group is going to hve a whole lot of sympathy for his selective obedience of the orders of those appointed over him.

Have fun breaking rocks, El-Tee (soon to become Private E-1?). Be thankful that they don't stand you up against a wall wearing a blindfold, and pemanently remove you from the population of oxygen thieves.
Posted by: Lone Ranger   2007-02-04 19:04  

#1   and proposed that he be deployed to Afghanistan

!
I've oft proposed to the skool board that I be transferred to my proposed Highwayan School for purdy girls with no behavior problems.
Posted by: Shipman   2007-02-04 17:07  

00:00