| Submit your comments on this article |
| Home Front: Culture Wars |
| Get educated, become Republican (despite the professors' best efforts) |
| 2006-10-09 |
| An interesting perspective with actual statistics to back it up, in the Wall Street Journal's OpinionJournal.com. In one popular book about campus politics, the author writes, "We all know that left-wing radicals from the 1960s have hung around academia and hired people like themselves. . . . They spew violent anti-Americanism, preach anti-Semitism, and cheer on the killing of American soldiers and civilians--all the while collecting tax dollars and tuition fees to indoctrinate our children." Most studies of the subject have indicated that, indeed, upward of 90% of college professors at many universities hold liberal political views. In some schools and departments, faculties are virtually 100% left-wing. It is one thing to lament this ideological lopsidedness in the academy. But it is quite another to assume that professors actually bend the little minds in their care toward a liberal point of view, or even a radical one. The evidence says, probably not: When it comes to politics, people from conservative families follow their parents, not their professors. The most recent evidence on this subject comes from the mid-1990s, in the University of Michigan's National Election Studies. I would be interested to know how the numbers changed post-9/11. These survey data uncover two facts. First, people who go to college are more likely to vote Republican than those who don't go to college. Adults 25 and under from Republican homes are, for example, 11 percentage points more likely to vote Republican if they attended college than if they didn't. And young adults from Democratic households are 11 percentage points less likely to vote Democrat if they've gone to college than if not. Second, nearly everybody grows more likely to vote Republican as they age--but especially college graduates. It is no shock that the vast majority of people of all educational backgrounds from Republican homes vote Republican by age 40. It may come as more of a surprise that 40-year-olds with Democrat parents are far less likely to vote Democrat if they've gone to college than if they haven't. In fact, while three-quarters of the uneducated group still vote Democrat, the odds are only about 50-50 that the college graduates vote this way. And they've not all become skeptical political independents: Fully a third are registered Republicans. Obviously, some kids turn left in college--but this appears to be the exception, not the rule. Does all this mean that our colleges and universities are actually breeding grounds for conservatism? Hardly. What the statistics really show is that higher education by itself doesn't affect political views very much. Rather, in addition to the strong influence of parents, it is higher incomes--which typically reward a college education in America--that push people to the right politically. In Republican families, the income effect reinforces parents' influence on their kids. In Democratic families, the two effects work against each other. While I wasn't worried about pontificating idiots actually converting the trailing daughters (they read Rantburg), that doesn't reduce the annoyance at having my [future] college fees, and the trailing daughters' learning time, thusly wasted. Mr. Brooks, a professor at Syracuse University's Maxwell School of Public Affairs, is the author of "Who Really Cares: The Surprising Truth About Compassionate Conservatism," forthcoming in November from Basic Books. |
| Posted by:trailing wife |
| #6 I would tend to think that the real hysteric professors are in unmarketable disciplines like indian studies, sociology and similar crap. In disciplines who lead to big bucks like engineering a) professors could be more conservative (otherwise they would be teaching a moonabat discipline) b) many of those disciplines don't lend well to indoctrination (eg maths, physics) and c) Pressure is greater both from alumni and university fpr professor really teaching instead of indoctrinating because ignorant and politicized students sell poorly in teh market and this affects univeristy's reputation and on the long term teacher's salary. So I think the revenue effect is not so important for people becoming conservative than the vaccination effect. To take my own example after the Cambodian genocide I became very resentful against the people who had indoctrinated me and in addition were completely unrepentant of having supported the Khmer Rouge. Now I am a neocon. |
| Posted by: JFM 2006-10-09 17:40 |
| #5 You spew nonsense all day to a captive audience and you will spawn two concequences (1) An ability to say what the teacher wants in order to get a good grade (2) critical thinking because at some point the nonsense will be obvious, thus making the rest of it suspect. Critical thinking is all that I ask from our education system. Everything else is a bonus. |
| Posted by: rjschwarz 2006-10-09 16:06 |
| #4 &%$#@!*&$? You have 2 characters there too many. ;-) |
| Posted by: twobufour 2006-10-09 14:47 |
| #3 Sheesh |
| Posted by: GORT 2006-10-09 13:00 |
| #2 TW - Yeah, the idea of my dough being sent to bald pony-tailed idiots does gall. But my worries over the impact college professors would have over my sons while at college went away after a few weeks. During one of the all-to infrequent calls home, I asked about the professors. My oldest stated "Their &%$#@!*&$ a$$holes Dad." I'm so proud - (wipes tear) |
| Posted by: GORT 2006-10-09 12:58 |
| #1 This shouts "REPUBLICANS SHOULD INVEST IN TAX CUTS" Why is anyone suprised that talented people want to see less of the money they earned extorted from them by the state? |
| Posted by: Bright Pebbles in Blairistan 2006-10-09 12:57 |