You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Israel-Palestine-Jordan
UN envoy says Gaza a prison for Palestinians
2006-09-27
GENEVA - Israel has turned the Gaza Strip into a prison for Palestinians where life is “intolerable, appalling, tragic” and the Jewish state appears to have thrown away the key, a UN human rights envoy said on Tuesday.
Got everything right except the 'cause-effect' part.
UN special wrapper rapporteur on human rights in the occupied Palestinian territory John Dugard said that the suffering of the Palestinians was a test of the readiness of the international community to protect human rights. “If ... the international community cannot ... take some action, (it) must not be surprised if the people ... disbelieve that they are seriously committed to the promotion of human rights,” he told the United Nations’ Human Rights Council.
The international community generally isn't committed to human rights, it's committed to talking about human rights. That's a difference a special wrapper of the UN should understand.
Israel hit back saying there was an “alarming disconnect” between the rapporteur’s report to the UN’s human rights watchdog and the experience of Israelis who continued to “face the daily threat of Palestinian terrorism”.
'Alarming disconnect' is the proper diplomatic form of "You idiot! Pay Attention to what you're seeing!"
The South African lawyer, who has been a special UN investigator since 2001, repeated earlier accusations that Israel is breaking international humanitarian law with security measures which amount to “collective punishment.”
Since the Paleos seem to be in it together, it's appropriate to keep them all away from the Israelis.
Israel says its security restrictions, which include the construction of a steel and concrete barrier in the West Bank, are designed to stop suicide bombers entering Israel. Bombings have declined since the barrier was built.
Which the special wrapper didn't notice: it's hard to see the gore that hasn't been splattered.
It also maintains tight restrictions on the movement of goods and people into and out of Gaza, a coastal strip that it pulled out of last year after 38 years of occupation.
Especially the guns and ammo.
Dugard also attacked the United States, the European Union and Canada for withdrawing funding for the Palestinian Authority in protest at the governing party Hamas’s refusal to accept Israel’s right to exist. “Israel violates international law as expounded by the Security Council and the International Court of Justice and goes unpunished. But the Palestinian people are punished for having democratically elected a regime unacceptable to Israel, the US and the EU,” Dugard said.
The Paleos have a right to elect crazed killers to lead their government. We have a right not to give cash to crazed killers. That's one of our rights under that vaunted international law of yours, you could look it up.
But Israel’s ambassador to the UN in Geneva Itzhak Levanon said that by putting the “entire blame” on Israel the report ”absolves the terrorists that have taken Palestinian society hostage from even the most minimal responsibility.”
You're trying to talk sense to a special wrapper and that doesn't work ...
Dugard said that three-quarters of GazaÂ’s 1.4 million people were dependent on food aid.
Stop the food aid and the Paleos might finally wake up. Cold but true.
Bombing raids by Israel since the June 25 capture of an army corporal by Palestinian militants had destroyed houses and the territory’s only power plant. “Gaza is a prison and Israel seems to have thrown away the key,” he said.
It's just not enough of a prison yet for the Paleos to come to their senses.
Posted by:Steve White

#15  "I cry out to God
seeking only his decision
Gabriel stands and confirms
I've created my own prison"


---Creed
Posted by: mcsegeek1   2006-09-27 12:18  

#14  The UN never cared much about the timorese, for that matter, nor the southern sudanese... first a vehicle for third-worldism and marxists (as Pacepa explained), now a vehicle for tranzis and West-haters, with muslim pulling the strings with their deep pockets, and chinese playing their games.
Posted by: anonymous5089   2006-09-27 11:59  

#13  It never ceases to amaze me that they spend more time worrying about paleos, where much of the tragedy is self-inflicted, than they do on Darfur, where TENS OF THOUSANDS of people are being killed, raped, displaced.

The (current) victims in Darfur may be Muslim, but the perpetrators are also Muslim, and are seen as more Arab than the victims.

Didn't one of their leading intellectuals declare all the concern over the genocide campaigns in Sudan to be a Zionist conspiracy?
Posted by: Rob Crawford   2006-09-27 11:55  

#12  Well said Baby Tutu! The problem with the Pals (and most Arabs) is that they were never taught and have no inclination to become self sufficient. The un has institutionalized them to the point that they canÂ’t even take care of themselves. They donÂ’t know how to build a society, but they know how to make bombs, that alone should tell you a lot. I like the Swiss analogy. Switzerland has few natural resources, a small work force, and uses three languages, yet they are light years ahead of any Arab Middle Eastern society.
Posted by: Cyber Sarge   2006-09-27 11:08  

#11   Its starts daily - at about 2PM - when the UN 2-hour luncheon and martini ends. Twice on Friday.

You're forgetting Happy Hour.
Posted by: badanov   2006-09-27 10:53  

#10  Its starts daily - at about 2PM - when the UN 2-hour luncheon and martini ends. Twice on Friday.
Posted by: CrazyFool   2006-09-27 09:32  

#9  What time is the "imminent humanitarian crisis" starting?
Again.
Posted by: tu3031   2006-09-27 08:26  

#8   . . . Gaza Strip into a prison for Palestinians where life is “intolerable, appalling, tragic” . . . the suffering of the Palestinians was a test of the readiness of the international community to protect human rights

It never ceases to amaze me that they spend more time worrying about paleos, where much of the tragedy is self-inflicted, than they do on Darfur, where TENS OF THOUSANDS of people are being killed, raped, displaced.

Any mention of the rockets fired into Israel, or weapons smuggling, all of which occured after Israel UNILATERALLY withdrew from Gaza? Any mention of the factional infighting? Any mention of the lack of productive, positive collaboration amongst paleos to create a better life? Any mention of the looting? Any mention of the destruction of property after the withdrawal?

Didn't think so.

"Collective punishment." It seems to me that it was the "collective" that brought Hamas into power. It is the "collective" that does nothing to stop rockets. It is the "collective" that does nothing to create a thriving community.

It is EXACTLY this sort of report that sustains hope for paleo victory and provides support for antagonism. It thwarts cooperation and compromise. Paleos think that these reports lend credibility to their plight and that world pressure will force Israel's hand. The UN is complicit in creating the very conditions they complain about.

What they don't realize is that the dynamic has changed. There is less sympathy for them now than there has been in a long time. Regardless, Israel will not succumb to pressure that will endanger her citizens.

The cluebat doesn't seem to be working. Get a bigger one.
Posted by: PlanetDan   2006-09-27 08:23  

#7  UN envoy says Gaza a prison for Palestinians

Interesting idea, worth pursuing.
Posted by: Robert Crawford   2006-09-27 05:12  

#6  suffering of the Palestinians was a test of the readiness of the international community to protect human rights

The principal being: the right to kill Jews.
Posted by: gromgoru   2006-09-27 05:04  

#5  One solution, kick the paleos out and reclaim Gaza for Israel.
Posted by: Captain America   2006-09-27 03:41  

#4  Israel has turned the Gaza Strip into a prison for Palestinians where life is “intolerable, appalling, tragic” and the Jewish state appears to have thrown away the key, a UN human rights envoy said on Tuesday.

John Dugard is either stupid or had a gun in his ear. Since he probably spoke to this reporter from his air-conditioned office in the UN, anybody not part of the UN can probably figure out the correct answer here.

I'd say the Paleostinians did it to themselves. And honestly they seem to enjoy it. Probably out of ignorance. As soon as they get smart and figure that out, things will get better.
Posted by: gorb   2006-09-27 02:04  

#3  Baba Tutu, don't reveal next year's Survivor - it will get Fred sued.
Posted by: Super Hose   2006-09-27 01:03  

#2  Suppose you were to take the entire population of Gaza and ship them someplace else, say Geneva, and replace them with a like number of Swiss citizens.

Does anyone doubt that in short order Geneva would become a fetid wasteland of violence and corruption, poverty stricken and shunned as hopeless and threatening by its neighbors, while the new Gaza would be peaceful, prosperous and open?

The problem isn't Israel. It's Palestinian culture. Can't be fixed by funding. They are going to have to want to change it for themselves. So far there's little sign they do, and therefore little reason for hope.
Posted by: Baba Tutu   2006-09-27 00:57  

#1  First time in history tht prisoners built their own prison then locked them selves into it and threw away the key.

See! Islam is innovative!
Posted by: CrazyFool   2006-09-27 00:50  

00:00