You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Afghanistan
Canadian troops capture Taliban suspects
2006-05-12
Some details changed to protect the privacy of captured Taliban, in accordance with the Geneva conventions.
Canadian soldiers in Afghanistan have captured 10 suspected Taliban fighters. The capture came as Canadian troops were escorting a convoy to Gumbad, north of Kandahar, where Canada maintains a forward operating base. The soldiers noticed two groups apparently conducting a reconnaissance of the area. CBC correspondent Peter Armstrong reported from Kandahar that Canadian units had been scouring the hills trying to flush out Taliban fighters. The Canadians were given a tip that a group was hiding in a compound, "so troops moved in and essentially, without firing a shot," captured the men, Armstrong reported.
"Sergeant Major!"
"Huh? Sir, the sergeant major's..."
"Bring up the death ray!"
"The... what?"
"We quit! We're coming out!"
Members of 1st Princess Patricia's Canadian Light Infantry carried out the raid. Ten suspects were subsequently handed over to the Afghan National Police. "We've taken some bad guys off the street," Maj. Marc Theriault told a news briefing in Kandahar.
"Book 'em, Mahmoud!"
A photographer with Agence France-Presse was embedded with the unit and captured images of Canadian troops processing the detainees and taking them into custody. At first, the Canadian military asked the photographer not to publish the images.
"Careful with those photos, eh? They're dangerous!"
"Who the hell are you?"
"Jones, Attorney at Law, representing the prisoners!"
Military officials said their lawyers reviewed the photos and thought they might be in violation of the Geneva Conventions, which says that a picture holding up a prisoner to ridicule may not be released. Article 13 of the convention states: "Prisoners of war must at all time be protected, particularly against acts of violence or intimidation and against insults and public curiosity."
"Sergeant Major!"
"Uhhh... Sir!"
"Is the death ray ready?"
"No. Wait. I've changed my mind, eh? You can use the photos. They're just routine stuff."
However, the military later said it was up to the various news agencies to decide whether they wanted to publish the images.
Good news, bad news? Make what you will of this. At least the headline seemed exciting.
Posted by:Snavise Uleatch2308

#3  #2 It's complicated, GE1163. You have to be a 'trained observer', an 'analyst', or an 'expert' to see the differentiation.

an agenda, thatr helps too.
Posted by: Brougham Bro   2006-05-12 10:55  

#2  It's complicated, GE1163. You have to be a 'trained observer', an 'analyst', or an 'expert' to see the differentiation.
Posted by: Seafarious   2006-05-12 09:41  

#1  how do the Taliban fall under the Geneva convention when they are not a uniformed military force or outright gov in Afghanistan anymore?
Posted by: Greamp Elmavinter1163   2006-05-12 09:31  

00:00