| Submit your comments on this article |
| Down Under |
| Australian Cartoon in poor taste: Indonesia |
| 2006-04-01 |
| INDONESIA today described as "tasteless" a caricature in The Weekend Australian newspaper depicting President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono as a dog. The publication of the cartoon followed a similar drawing in an Indonesian daily portraying Prime Minister John Howard and his Foreign Minister Alexander Downer as copulating dingoes. The cartoon war comes amid tensions between Jakarta and Canberra over Australia's decision to grant refugee visas to 42 asylum-seekers from Indonesia's restive Papua province. Vote: What do you think? Presidential spokesman Andi Mallarangeng said Mr Yudhoyono had not seen the Australian caricature but the president "laughed" when told of the depiction. "It's in poor taste. Sometimes the media, both in Indonesia and other countries, resort to poor taste, which actually demonstrates the level of their quality," Mr Mallarangeng saud. The Australian cartoon, drawn by award-winning cartoonist Bill Leak, shows Mr Yudhoyono as a tail-wagging dog mounting a startled-looking Papua dog and saying "don't take this the wrong way". The caption under the cartoon reads "no offence intended". On Monday Indonesian tabloid Rakyat Merdeka ran a front-page caricature showing Mr Howard being mounted on Downer with the Prime Minister saying: "I want Papua!! Alex! Try to make it happen." Mr Howard dismissed the Indonesian cartoon, although Mr Downer described it as grotesque and "way below standards of public taste". Downer responded to the latest cartoon by saying the Australian Government in no way condoned it. "Editors have responsibility to be mindful of the consequences of what they publish, particularly when they knowingly publish material that is likely to be found offensive in some quarters," Mr Downer said. The Australian embassy in Jakarta had been alerted to possible fallout from the Mr Leak's cartoon. "We have been in communication with our embassy," Mr Downer said. "They have concerns that there will be a negative reaction by the Indonesians to material like this which is extremely offensive." Indonesia has been stung by the decision of Australia's immigration department to issue three-year visas to the group of Papuans, including prominent separatists and their families, who arrived by boat in northern Australia in January. In response, Indonesia has recalled its ambassador to Canberra, postponed an agreement on jointly fighting bird flu, and angry Indonesians have protested outside the Australian embassy in Jakarta. Since the decision, Mr Howard has repeatedly stated his support for Indonesian sovereignty over Papua, a former Dutch colony taken over by Jakarta in the 1960s. |
| Posted by:Oztrailan |
| #3 I said "americans" I should have said westerners. |
| Posted by: 2b 2006-04-01 10:52 |
| #2 These insulting cartoon events are like the Mexican Flags flying at the immigrant rallies - I just don't think that they understand what type of effect they are causing for Americans. I guess provacateurs are like generals - always fighting the last war. Times have changed and they aren't helping their own causes with these events, they are seriously hurting it. |
| Posted by: 2b 2006-04-01 10:52 |
#1 Cartoon's at the link. The cartoon it was in response to:
Can be seen here. As far as I can tell, this cartoon was drawn explicitly to give offense. There's nothing in the actual issue which demands, or even suggests, dog buggery, or illicit relations (personal or political) between Howard and Downer. I suspect the cartoonist's point was less about New Guinea, and more about the Danish cartoons. "Ha! Let's see what you think when you're the one being insulted!" Howard shrugged. |
| Posted by: Angie Schultz 2006-04-01 10:21 |