| Submit your comments on this article |
| International-UN-NGOs |
| The pope's unexploded bombshell |
| 2006-01-24 |
| by Diana West Remember when word came down from the Vatican that Pope John Paul II had watched Mel Gibson's "The Passion of the Christ" and liked it? The anonymously sourced story sparked a media firestorm around the globe as reporters sought confirmation of the papal equivalent of two thumbs up. "It is as it was," we later learned the pope supposedly said. Which sounded like the perfect biblical movie blurb; but did the pontiff actually utter the words? After some non-clarifying retractions from the Vatican, it was ultimately hard to say for sure -- although not for journalistic want of trying. This natural curiosity stands in striking contrast to the media silence that has met a far more sensational, far more significant report of papal opinion: namely, that Pope Benedict XVI is said to believe that Islam is incapable of reform. This bombshell dropped out of an early January interview conducted by radio host Hugh Hewitt with the Rev. Joseph D. Fessio, SJ, a friend and former student of the pope. The Rev. Fessio recounted the pope's words on the key problem facing Islamic reform this way: "In the Islamic tradition, God has given His word to Muhammad, but it's an eternal word. It's not Muhammad's word. It's there for eternity the way it is. There's no possibility of adapting it or interpreting it." Fessio continued, elaborating not on how many ratings stars the pope thinks some biopic should get, but rather on the pope's theological assessment of a historically warring religion with a billion-plus followers, some notorious number of whom are now at war with the West. According to his friend, the pope believes there's no way to change Islam because there's no way to reinterpret the Koran -- i.e., change Koranic teachings on infidels, women, polygamy, penal codes and other markers of Islamic law -- in such a way as to propel Islam into happy coexistence with modernity. Rest at link. |
| Posted by:ed |
| #3 Doesn't seem to much of a denial: The meeting was an informal one of the Holy Father and his former students. The presentation and the discussion were in German, and the Holy Father was not speaking from a prepared text. My German is passable but not entirely reliable. My later remarks in a live radio interview were extemporaneous. I think I paraphrased the Holy Father with general accuracy, but it was an indiscretion for me to mention what he said at all, and my impromptu paraphrase in another language should not be used for a careful exegesis of the mind of the Holy Father. The gist: The pope said it, but he may not have used those exact words. And if you try to pin me down to exactly the words used, I claim ignorance of German. Please don't fatwa my ass. |
| Posted by: ed 2006-01-24 14:14 |
#2 Original source for bombshell has retracted key part of his statement the Holy Father did not say, nor did I, that "Islam is incapable of reform." |
| Posted by: Whutch Threth6418 2006-01-24 10:26 |
| #1 Within the narrow context of Islam as a religion "worthy of belief", the Pope is gener correct as the word died with Mohammed himself. i.e. no way to prove or disprove, except by the study and close analysis of supra-normal or extra-normal events, prophecies and phenomenon. plus of course the quality of Muslim life and civilization. To use MARIAN APPARITIONS as example, "Mary" has appeared, in clearly anatatomically-corect "human" apparition, before massed crowds consisting of both believer, non-believer, secularist and athiest, etc. alike, so has "Jesus", Prophets and Saints. No such characteristic can be claimed, however, to my knowledge for "Mohammedan" apparitions or visions per se, iff any, MadMoud notwithstanding. |
| Posted by: JosephMendiola 2006-01-24 01:39 |