You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Politix
Iraq several years behind Afghanistan, sez Rummy
2005-11-19
US Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfeld dismissed on Friday growing calls for the United States to start withdrawing forces from Iraq, saying Iraq was several years behind Afghanistan as a secure country.
Now, just take a deep breath and think back. Who would have expected a statement like that in November, 2001?
Rumsfeld said as Iraqi forces took more control of their own security, it would enable US forces to be diverted to other assignments within Iraq. “What you’ll see over the period ahead is that the Iraqi security forces will be handed over responsibility for pieces of real estate, for certain types of missions and assignments,” Rumsfeld told reporters after talks with Australian ministers. “As that happens, the people who were engaged in those activities, they will in many cases assume other assignments and responsibilities, in many cases assisting help to train some additional Irai security forces,” said Rumsfeld.

The US Senate on Tuesday resolved that Iraqis should start to take the lead in their own security from next year, to allow a phased withdrawal of US troops. But the Senate rejected a Democrats demand for Republican President George W. Bush to submit a time-table for the troop withdrawal.
Posted by:Fred

#8  Hmmm...I don't see Iraq becoming friends with Iran. I just don't see it. If they become "friends" initally, it will be like goodwill shared between Hitler and Stalin.
Posted by: 2b   2005-11-19 22:08  

#7  I agree with anonymous2u. I do believe that when the Shiite use for the "Crusaders" end, they will demand we leave and we won't be able to resist cause we are fighting a Social Sevices campaign, not a war of conquest and conversion, which is what Islam is fighting. Civil war will erupt and the Sunnis will be conquered or driven out. The Kurds may get a relatively peaceful partition, depending on how well armed they are. I don't know which. The Shiite part, at least, will end up an Iran Lite.
Posted by: ed   2005-11-19 21:49  

#6  let a few Sunnis and their car bombs respond and they'll look like Dems defending Murtha
Posted by: Frank G   2005-11-19 21:18  

#5  I read over at Samizdata that after the elections, Sistani's fatwahing for US to leave.

They're not going to do it violently, they're going to peacefully protest.

---(Under the Tet Offensive post--

Already aides of Sistani have said "after Dec elections, fatwah will be issued ordering occupation out, and it will be backed by non-violent action." In other words, just as soon as the Shi'a have decided that they don't need to use us anymore to die and pay for their war with the Sunnis, 15 million Shi'a will go sit on every road into Iraq, letting us travel in only one direction--out. ....

Posted by: anonymous2u   2005-11-19 12:54  

#4  
Shhhhh the war's over we've won.
Posted by: Shipman   2005-11-19 12:23  

#3  Take the longer view. Iraq is a done deal. However, its strategic location is such that its security is in jeopardy from Iran.

This is important. More and more I'm reading this same double-entendre from the administration and the military leaders in Iraq. They very carefully phrase what they say so that if you don't pay attention, it sounds like they are talking about the insurgency; when in fact, they are placing Iraq in a higher, regional context.

They aren't preparing Iraq for an ineffectual insurgency, they are preparing it to defend itself against Iran--and possibly win.
Posted by: Anonymoose   2005-11-19 11:24  

#2  I agree with JAB, but I didn't know Anbar was in Syria.
Posted by: Curt Simon   2005-11-19 07:35  

#1  Basically, in his best case scenario we're going to be focusing on Al Queda in Anbar province while the Iraqis handle the rest of the country.
Posted by: JAB   2005-11-19 04:12  

00:00