You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Iraq-Jordan
Fallujah: From insurgent stronghold to `safest city in Iraq'
2005-03-23
Piles of rubble still line the streets here, but a few shops have opened on the main drag, schools are finally in session and a compensation program to help families rebuild made some token initial payments this month. Four months after the assault on Fallujah, in the center of Iraq's Sunni Muslim heartland, American forces working to rebuild the city say they're seeing some progress, albeit limited, in a city that's still blockaded and under a curfew. Even a little progress is an important development in a city that's been a major test for the American presence in Iraq.

On March 31, 2004, four U.S. contractors were ambushed and killed here, setting off a battle when U.S. Marines tried unsuccessfully to dislodge the insurgent forces that had taken control of the city. The second battle began in November, when U.S. Army and Marine units moved through the city, destroying buildings and killing hundreds of opponents. Now the reconstruction effort faces a problem - how to get life back to normal while preventing another uprising. The American forces say they're insisting that the Iraqi government take the lead and they admit that the work ahead will be slow going.

A group of Iraqi men shoveling dirt and sand in a vacant lot said much about the effort. "They're making big piles into little piles," joked one Marine, as he guided a group of journalists on a tour of the city this week. The Marines could do the job in a couple of hours with a front-end loader but prefer to pay military-age men to get it done with the tools they have - giving the men an alternative to working with the insurgents and a chance for Iraqis to lead the reconstruction effort. "If we did everything, we could do this faster," said Master Sgt. Leon Brown, of the Army's 445th Battalion, a reservist from Milpitas, Calif. "But how are the Iraqi people going to feel confident about their country or their government?"
Posted by:Fred

#8  I think the final toll was around 4,000 killed and captured in Falluja. The US lost around 130 dead and the Iraqi troops lost about 10 dead. The kill ratio was therefore 10-15:1, which is amazing for an infantry led urban assualt.
Posted by: ed   2005-03-23 2:07:16 PM  

#7  Very true, BaR, but the break allowed the civilians to leave and more Hard Boyz to arrive to defend their stronghold. So, while frustrating all around, this allowed the environment to be even more target rich. I seem to recall estimates of 15000 captured/killed during the recent operation, and a kill ratio of something like 100:1.
Posted by: trailing wife   2005-03-23 1:33:19 PM  

#6  On March 31, 2004, four U.S. contractors were ambushed and killed here, setting off a battle when U.S. Marines tried unsuccessfully to dislodge the insurgent forces that had taken control of the city.

Uhhh, no. Had there not been a "suspension of offensive operations" declared, the Marines would have kicked the you-know-what out of the insurgents the first time around, instead of having to go through the whole thing a second time.
Posted by: Bomb-a-rama   2005-03-23 1:00:12 PM  

#5  Shovelling by hand keeps the eyes engaged for the presence of IEDs.
Posted by: john   2005-03-23 11:02:13 AM  

#4  An Iraqi Flight School:pileit here,then pileit over there.
Posted by: raptor   2005-03-23 8:52:52 AM  

#3  . "They're making big piles into little piles,"

Teaching the locals Paris Island engineering techniques.
Posted by: Shipman   2005-03-23 6:27:48 AM  

#2  Najaf is also pretty safe. Haven't heard anything from Sadr city either. Draw your conclusions.
Posted by: ed   2005-03-23 12:26:56 AM  

#1  Yes, despite the seemingly positive headline, it seems the author can't quite escape from the the "quagmire" mold!
Posted by: Bobby   2005-03-23 12:18:13 AM  

00:00