You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Syria-Lebanon-Iran
Iran has broken Western alliance against its nuclear activities: analyst
2005-01-23
Political analyst and nuclear physicist Ali Khorram said here on Saturday that achieving scientific and industrial development is the key for Iran's success in its nuclear talks with the European Union. Until six months ago, not many people were aware of Iran's scientific progress and nuclear status, and this also influenced the process of the nuclear talks, Khorram told the Mehr News Agency. But after International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Director General Mohamed ElBaradei's reports revealed Iran's scientific and industrial expertise in regard to the nuclear fuel cycle and centrifuge construction, its nuclear status actually served as an engine for Iran's diplomacy, he said.

This scientific development made European countries and the United States realize that they could no longer persuade Iran to abandon its nuclear fuel cycle program, Khorram stressed. It also proved that threats to attack Iran's nuclear installations would not be effective, since nuclear technology has taken root in Iran, he added. Khorram, who served for years as Iran's representative on UN disarmament and human rights commissions, noted that the fact that the Islamic Republic made it known that it might withdraw from the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) was another factor that helped expedite the process of nuclear talks. He stressed that the right to withdraw from the NPT is stipulated in the treaty as a clear right for all signatories, adding that a country which withdraws from the NPT has committed no wrong according to international law.
Posted by:Fred

#9  The Germans are desperate to increase exports. The high euro is killing any chance for economic growth in Germany and France this year. The only "negotiation" here is the terms which the Iranians will dictate to the EU3. It's the Iranians who are holding out the carrot, not the EU3.
Posted by: lex   2005-01-23 4:24:57 PM  

#8  Barbara, it seems to me the Euro thinking on the matter goes something like, "Well, we wouldn't nuke Iran, so why would they nuke us? Whereas that horrible Bush wants to attack them. Q.E.D." They honestly don't seem to have got as far as hungry crocodiles. Not high level thinking in my opinion, but then I'm American, too. ;-)
Posted by: trailing wife   2005-01-23 2:51:00 PM  

#7  What "Western alliance" against Iran's nuclear activities?

D'ya think they mean us, the Aussies, the Israelis, and (maybe) the Brits?

The continental Euros aren't against it; they want to sell Iran equipment. And they not-so-secretly hope Iran will nuke Israel and the US.

Guess they think the Iranian nuclear crocodile will eat them last....
Posted by: Barbara Skolaut   2005-01-23 11:39:58 AM  

#6  Yes,yes. Europeans are a valuable allies.
Posted by: gromgorru   2005-01-23 11:31:17 AM  

#5  Let's be clear. A theocratically ran Iran with nukes is the equivalent of giving prominent terrorist groups nuke weaponry. Bush Doctrine warns of the nexus between terrorists and WMD. Now, how many al Qaeda are in Iran?
Posted by: Captain America   2005-01-23 1:37:26 AM  

#4  The green ones, are fascists for openspace.
The aqua ones, are fascists for whale watching.
Posted by: raise your hand   2005-01-23 1:16:57 AM  

#3  Then the only feasible option is to let the Israelis do the dirty work. So be it.
Posted by: lex   2005-01-23 1:06:23 AM  

#2  Lex, while I like your aims and clear understanding of the widespread nationalism of Iranians, it would seem we are approaching a fork in the road.

For very pragmatic reasons, we cannot allow a nuclear Iran and the probability of an overwhelming democratic revolt in advance of the theocracy govern nuclear Iran is remote.

The sands in the hour glass are running low, a democratic coup is not probable any time soon, and a theocracy with nukes is virtually certain in arguably a year to year and a half.
Posted by: Captain America   2005-01-23 12:58:07 AM  

#1  A brilliant tactical maneuver: this Iranian is trying to recast Iran's nuclear drive in purely nationalist terms: he presents Iran's deceptions and nuclear march as a sign of national "scientific progress" and a source of national pride.

This should be a warning to both Bush and the EU Dwarves. The goal here should be to enable the Iranian democratic opposition by every means at our disposal, accelerate the overthrow of the mullahs, and do so in a way that emphasizes our solidarity with Iranian democratic nationalism. Bush should signal that we have no problems with a nuclear Iran, provided that such an Iran be governed by the people, not fascistic bloodthirsty mullahs determined to obliterate Israel and to strangle Iraqi democracy.
Posted by: lex   2005-01-23 12:20:55 AM  

00:00