You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Down Under
Et tu, Sydney?
2004-12-04
Sydney Mayor Clover Moore has been cast as the Grinch who stole Christmas after decorating her city's town hall with just one meagre Christmas tree out of fear of offending non-Christians. Moore has been accused of political correctness gone mad after residents in Australia's largest city woke to newspaper headlines demanding "Where's Our Christmas?" and complaints the city had not done enough to celebrate the festive season. Sydney's The Daily Telegraph compared Sydney's Scrooge-like approach with opulent Christmas displays in major capitals like London, New York and Paris. It invited readers to send a cutout postcard, depicting Moore as children's author Dr Seuss' famous character, the Grinch, to the Town Hall in complaint.
"You're a mean one, Ms. Grinch."
"Christmas is a time of wonder, fun and festivities, for young and old. As the nation's premier city...surely we deserve better," the paper said. Talkback radio programmes were flooded with calls and even conservative Prime Minister John Howard joined in. "This is political correctness from central casting. It is unbelievable," Howard told Sydney radio 2UE. "This is the ridiculous thing about this blanding out of any kind of distinctive identity we might have. Christmas is not only a religious festival...it is also part of the history and culture of this country," he said.

Moore defended her approach to the holiday season, saying Sydney had this year spent A$300,000 ($NZ325,624.38) more on decorations around the city than in 2003. "Today, Christmas is a celebration for everyone and I'd like to encourage everyone to get out in the city and celebrate and I especially urge building owners and retailers throughout the city to get into the Christmas spirit," she said in a statement. Sydney is a multicultural city of some 4 million people, with about 200 separate ethnic groups represented, according to official figures.
Posted by:Korora

#11  My wife is Hindu, she LOVES Christmas and all the traditional trappings that go with it.
LOL! That's because has one RB Denizen (maybe you?) put it, she understands that Santa is really a blue Elephant with a beautiful garland of white flowers.
Posted by: Shipman   2004-12-04 7:10:07 PM  

#10  But Ms. Moore and Sydney will always have Ramadan. Bring out the goat sacrifices.
Posted by: ed   2004-12-04 3:21:27 PM  

#9  "I'm sure the Hindus in Sydney will be happy she's not offending them with a big ol' wreath."

My wife is Hindu, she LOVES Christmas and all the traditional trappings that go with it. She isn't the least bit bothered by Christmas Trees, Carolling (sp), presents etc. etc. Don't get between her and her turkey and dressing either.

-AR
Posted by: Analog Roam   2004-12-04 3:14:07 PM  

#8  Guys, this season check the schedule for the History Channel's program the History of Christmas. Surprises in store - like, did you know the New England Puritans banned Christmas because of its pagan origins? The modern version which we celebrate is attributed to New York merchants of the early 19th century?

It is interesting though that most of these PC actions are just fronts for people in power to carry out their anti-Christian agenda. Those of us who have been stationed in Japan and S.Korea have witnessed countries of non-Judeo-Christian heritage celebrate the season with just as much joy as any Redlander; lights, sales, and even Santa, in cultures more oriented to Buddism or Taoism.
Posted by: Don   2004-12-04 9:45:03 AM  

#7  JFM - Nah, you're not alone. I don't think the Aussies would really have cared if she put other, non-Christian things up, like a bunch of other places have done to avoid offending someone.
Looks like they were just used to having the place decorated this time of year, and since it only had a very small tree, people felt let down. I work in a government agency, and we have a bunch of secular decorations (pine and glitter garlands, a big ol' tree with "gifts" underneath and snowmen). No one's ever complained about it, and believe me, there are members of the public who will bitch about damn near anything.
Posted by: Desert Blondie   2004-12-04 9:43:14 AM  

#6  .... The Daily Telegraph compared Sydney’s Scrooge-like approach with opulent Christmas displays in major capitals like London, New York and Paris.
Damn. I'll have to read more of those Telegraph columns. Until now I was completly unaware that New York City was the capital of anything.
Posted by: GK   2004-12-04 9:31:00 AM  

#5  I am the only one who noticed that we are taliking
of Christmas?
Posted by: JFM   2004-12-04 7:08:23 AM  

#4  First she minimises the official celebration of Christmas, proving that she's much more concerned about Muslims and radical left atheists than she is about Christians. Then, under great public pressure, she does an about-face and makes a pretence of all-inclusive benevolence by inviting "everyone" to celebrate Christmas.

It's a curious left-wing mix of stubborn, blind idealism and gross hypocrisy.



Posted by: Bryan   2004-12-04 6:47:46 AM  

#3  "Today, Christmas is a celebration for everyone and I’d like to encourage everyone to get out in the city and celebrate and I especially urge building owners and retailers throughout the city to get into the Christmas spirit," she said in a statement.

Huh??? If she was afraid of offending non-Christians, why the encouragment for "everyone" to celebrate Christmas?
Posted by: Bomb-a-rama   2004-12-04 1:47:35 AM  

#2  Obviously - No election soon...
Posted by: BigEd   2004-12-04 1:40:56 AM  

#1  I'm sure the Hindus in Sydney will be happy she's not offending them with a big ol' wreath. You know how they get.....not to mention the Buddhists and Wiccans.
Posted by: Desert Blondie   2004-12-04 12:23:24 AM  

00:00