You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: WoT
Monkey See, Monkey Do - Not An Islamic Ideal
2004-10-13
The other day, a friend mentioned that a fellow Muslim had declared that we should be careful about condemning the recent massacre of innocent schoolchildren in Russia by so-called "Islamic militants" because "some scholars" have issued "fatwas" (non-binding legal opinions) that such operations are sometimes acceptable under Islamic Law.
As I've mentioned before, any idiot can issue a fatwah, and many do...
They then referenced part of a Qur'anic verse which basically means, "
 then whoever transgresses the prohibition against you, you transgress likewise against him." (Qur'an 2:194). Essentially, this is the age old "an eye for an eye" legal maxim that dates back to not just the Old Testament, but to the Code of Hammurabi as well. While this maxim might be rightfully employed in individual cases of justice, using it to justify mass murder and collective punishment is quite a stretch.
Using it to massacre schoolchildren is definitely a stretch.
Being informed that a Muslim in my community adhered to such shoddy logic rather shocked and disgusted me even though I'm well aware of the half-baked and ethically shallow justifications of suicide bombing espoused by some Muslims. In spite of that, being ambivalent about the massacre of innocent schoolchildren seemed to expose a moral depravity that's sunk to all new levels.
Either that, or a simple lack of morality, an utter lack of a soul. There's not even anything there to go to Hell when he dies...
Posted by:tipper

#2  Want to see what some clearly intelligent Muslims have to say about current events, then go to http://abbaskadhim.blogspot.com/. It ain't pretty, but you've seen it before. All deflection, blame America, blame the Joooooos, etc. I go over there for a laugh, but in the end it is sadly educational. I sure hope that there is change amongst the peoples of the Ummah.
Posted by: remote man   2004-10-13 4:38:17 PM  

#1  If Islam is ever to reform, it's going to need more guys like this, writing essays like this, to be willing to take the risk. There are people out there quite willing to behead the author in order to shut him up. God protect him.
Posted by: Mike   2004-10-13 12:23:19 PM  

00:00