You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Culture Wars
Fish Amnesty Day
2004-09-30
ELF - reg. required
Go fishing. Take a kid fishing. Go out for a seafood dinner. That is the best retaliation for PETA's latest quirky, angler-insulting, ridiculous anti-fishing campaign.
Tenderize a trout with a claw hammer!
People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, who declared last Saturday "Fish Amnesty Day," are seeking to make every day fish amnesty day and now are urging fishermen to turn in their rods and reels, to hang up their tackle. I can't imagine anyone who enjoys fishing actually surrendering his or her gear to PETA for use in anti-fishing demonstrations. Most fishermen would burn their gear rather than donate it to PETA. As a reminder to outdoorsmen--as if they need it--PETA opposes hunting, fishing and trapping and seeks to eradicate all of those activities. PETA also opposes dog mushing, rodeo and the circus. More recently, PETA seems to have adopted the notion everyone in the world should become vegetarians. The group recently poked fun at actor John Goodman and opera singer Luciano Pavarotti, whom they consider overweight, and demanded they change their eating habits. Now PETA has concluded fish feel pain and are being tortured when caught, even by fishermen who catch and release.
I'm sure they do. If somebody dragged me out of my room using a hook, I'd feel pain, too. But PETA's making the assumption that I care, which doesn't necessarily follow from the mere fact of the critter's pain.
This is just another absurd example of PETA equating a lower species on the food chain with humans. PETA's premise is that all animals are warm and cuddly. The organization even has someone on staff with the title of "Fish Empathy Project Manager."
I wonder if, after sitting and watching her guppies all day, the Fish Empathy Project Manager goes home and eats her young?
"There's nothing sporting about luring defenseless animals to their deaths with the promise of food," Fish Empathy specialist Karin Robertson said in a PETA press release.
It works better if you offer them food. I tried offering them money once, only got two bites all day, and one of 'em didn't pay me back...
Sometimes PETA supporters just make the looniest statements.
Noticed that, did ya? Not much gets by you!
On the group's Web site, Sylvia Earle, described as the former chief scientist for the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, is quoted as saying, "I never eat anyone I know personally. I wouldn't eat a grouper any more than I'd eat a cocker spaniel. They're so good-natured, so curious."
"Flounders, on the other hand, they're the hoodlums of the fish world, always skulking around. I'd eat a flounder in a flash! And all my grouper friends would, too!

Grouper?
They're really fun-loving. For fish.
"You know," she said, "fish really are sensitive. They have personalities. They hurt when they're wounded."
They eat their young. They eat each other's young. If one of 'em's wounded, the others will kill him...
How does she know?
Good question. I try not to answer that kind of question, because people who identify with fish frighten me. I'm sensitive that way. Not as sensitive as a grouper, mind you, but pretty sensitive.
PETA has a long way to go to persuade Americans to hang up their fishing tackle.
And you thought the LLL couldn't get any loonier.
Posted by:Spot

#23  PETA suggested this? I can just hear some Southerners reacting to this.

"Honey, grab the dynamite and the picture capturer, we're goin' fishing!"
Posted by: Charles   2004-09-30 7:34:36 PM  

#22  I had an Oscar and he ate everything else in the tank. Only a parrot I once had was meaner.
Posted by: Sgt. D.T.   2004-09-30 6:58:34 PM  

#21  There are three types of decent "pets"

DOGS -
CATS -
PARROT FAMILY - (PARROTS COCKATEILS BUDGIES etc)

OK NOW I WILL STICK MY FOOT IN MY MOUTH...

You have to be able to relate to, and not just look at and feed something. A fish, lizard, or turtle is no different than having nice roses in the garden... Rabbits and rodents only care about who feed them...
I.E. they are bait, or stew food...

Now that everybody hates me... Dogs and cats come to sleep on the bed with us at night...
They are only in trouble if they snore too loud...
Posted by: BigEd   2004-09-30 6:14:18 PM  

#20  I used to have a pet coelacanth, but he died a long time ago.
Posted by: SteveS   2004-09-30 4:04:27 PM  

#19  I'm fish-sitting this week while my friend is overseas..."Knit" and "Purl", two of the cutest damn goldfish you ever did see. They have their own castle an' everything...
Posted by: Seafarious   2004-09-30 3:53:01 PM  

#18  BAR - if you ever catch a Muskie, you'll need a club to persuade him to lie still in the bottom of the boat!!
Posted by: Doc8404   2004-09-30 3:51:34 PM  

#17  BAR - after the whacking they make good bobbers
Posted by: Frank G   2004-09-30 3:48:51 PM  

#16  Do these people go around and harass anglers in the field? I take my ex-roomate's kid fishing every now and then, and I just so happen to keep a club in the truck, just in case of problems. Having to deal with a PETA type could qualify as a "problem".
Posted by: Bomb-a-rama   2004-09-30 3:46:46 PM  

#15  In County Donegal up in the northwest part of Ireland there used to be a band called "An Emotional Fish." Always liked the name, heh heh.
Posted by: Alaska Paul   2004-09-30 3:20:42 PM  

#14  love plecos. never had em corycats as they are make for bad accidents with larger fish. my pleco was sole survivor in em buttikoferi nightmare im experiense. pet store guy was tell me buttekoferi in purdy non-agresive and im come home from work and find he was kill my oscars and green teror and snakehead.(that was upstate ny. they arent sell em in tx or ca) that was closest im ever come to perform fish euthanashia on pet fish. im put em big channel cat in the tank and he was not screw with that.
Posted by: muck4doo   2004-09-30 3:07:55 PM  

#13  You just can't imagine how well this is going to go over in south Louisiana. Does the amnesty include shrimp and crawfish?
Posted by: Matt   2004-09-30 3:07:14 PM  

#12  Big ED - Fish Co does have some good fare..puts Red Lobster to shame...
Posted by: Dan   2004-09-30 2:50:18 PM  

#11  I have tropical fish, Mucky - Plecostamus and Cory Cats right now - my largest and oldest Plecostamus died last month - 12 yrs old)
Posted by: Frank G   2004-09-30 2:49:46 PM  

#10  I used to have a pet largemouth bass. I caught him when he was a fingerling and raised him on goldfish. He lived comfortably in a 50-gallon tank with an Oscar. I eventually put him in a pond, when he was about a foot long, and no doubt somebody else caught him and ate him.
Posted by: Fred   2004-09-30 2:46:09 PM  

#9  taking fish out the wild for pets is a "no-no", and is need to be stopped. most fish peples keep for pets are tank raised and are need good homes. just like cats and dogs. im rather see tropcal fishes in em tanks than release in our lakes and streams for wreek havok. me and frank were have debate on that one time.
Posted by: muck4doo   2004-09-30 2:27:28 PM  

#8  Sorry Mucky, but keeping fish as "pets" is a no-no!
Posted by: Spot   2004-09-30 2:17:02 PM  

#7  
Fish Company, Los Alamitos, CA

Great Red Chowder!
Posted by: BigEd   2004-09-30 2:12:07 PM  

#6  Tuna steak for dinner tonight! Conincidental, but I'll toast the campaign.

I'm sure it's accidentally killed tuna though, mucky. Got caught up in a Japanese dolphin net...
Posted by: Bulldog   2004-09-30 2:09:35 PM  

#5  and some fish are emathize a nice human meal. seriously tho. some fishes are have lots of personality. anyone who is ever own an oscar can atest to that, but thatn exeption not rule. tetras are tend to be stoopid. my oscar i was used to have was always happy to see me and was like me to pet him. purdy cool fish. :)
Posted by: muck4doo   2004-09-30 2:02:06 PM  

#4  I would so totally give up meat, fish, hunting, fishing, leather, etc., if they said tomorrow we could hunt activists.
Posted by: John F*in Kerry   2004-09-30 1:53:27 PM  

#3  Fish....Why do they hate us?

I empathized a nice salmon steak last weekend and felt much better (and fuller) afterwards.
Posted by: Brett_the_Quarkian   2004-09-30 1:34:25 PM  

#2  How about zapping the Arafish today?
Posted by: True German Ally   2004-09-30 1:33:55 PM  

#1  
And you thought the LLL couldn’t get any loonier.
Actually, Spot, I didn't.
Posted by: Barbara Skolaut   2004-09-30 1:31:50 PM  

00:00