You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: WoT
US soldier tried for 'betrayal'
2004-08-31
A US soldier has gone on trial accused of trying to give away secrets to undercover agents who he allegedly thought were Islamic militants. Ryan Anderson, a Muslim convert serving in the US National Guard, is charged with trying to pass information to the al-Qaeda movement. His lawyer Maj Joseph Morse argued Mr Anderson suffered "a mental condition".
"Yer honor, my client's got a mental condition: he's a nut!"
But prosecuting lawyer Maj Melvin Jenks said the court-martial was "a case about betrayal".
"The fact that he's a nut don't matter!"
Mr Anderson, who was not present on the opening day of his trial, has pleaded innocent to five charges.
"Nope. Nope. Never happened. Wudn't me."
He faces life imprisonment if two-thirds of the officers on the panel in Fort Lewis, Washington state, find him guilty of the charges. Mr Anderson, 27, is alleged to have signed on to extremist internet chatrooms in order to contact al-Qaeda operatives to offer services and information. Maj Jenks said he had evidence from various sources, including text messages and email, showing Mr Anderson wanted to help enemy forces, Reuters reported. Mr Anderson is also accused of providing agents posing as al-Qaeda representatives with documents providing some specifics about army equipment. "This is a case about betrayal," Maj Jenks told a panel of commissioned officers on the opening day of the court-martial. "Betrayal of our country, betrayal of our army and betrayal of our soldiers."
"I object, yer honor! He called my client a dirtbag!"
"Overruled!"
But in his opening remarks, Maj Morse said Mr Anderson was suffering from delusions. "They [prosecutors] want you to believe he was a militant Muslim, that he sympathised with al-Qaeda," the defence lawyer said. "The evidence is not going to show it. He had a mental condition."
"He only thought he was a militant Muslim! Actually, he's a Lutheran!... With a turban... And curly-toed slippers. And automatic weapons..."
Maj Morse has previously argued the information Mr Anderson tried to pass on was not classified and was relatively easy to find. Mr Anderson was not of a senior rank and is not thought to have had access to highly sensitive information. The trial is expected to continue until at least Friday.
Posted by:tipper

#7  If he can be shown to know right from wrong, then simply export him as a perimeter "under the burkha" physical searcher in the boundary area of Fallujah. The Wannabee-Taliban there will save us the trouble.
Posted by: OldSpook   2004-08-31 11:43:26 PM  

#6  If he is suffering from a mental condition that predisposes him to treason, his command chain should be prosecuted for not being competent enough to realize that something was wrong and take action to remove him from access to classified or sensitive information. (system capabilities used to be classified Secret and deficiencies Top Secret). If he is sane, he should be tried for treason and executed.
Posted by: RWV   2004-08-31 4:49:38 PM  

#5  No insanity pleas allowed. Just hang him.
Posted by: BigEd   2004-08-31 10:54:30 AM  

#4  it’s also possible that most fanatics are just plain nuts. Not that your point isn’t valid…cause it is.
Posted by: B   2004-08-31 9:52:08 AM  

#3  Sorry to be the bubble-burster, but the guy actually could be just plain nuts. If not . . . well, that's a different story. Also, if he "had" a mental condition, chances are he still "has" it, and if so, it won't be very difficult for the panel to decipher.
Posted by: ex-lib   2004-08-31 9:39:07 AM  

#2  No need to click the link. Yes, the scare quotes are really there. Unbelievable!
Posted by: B   2004-08-31 8:43:56 AM  

#1  His lawyer Maj Joseph Morse argued Mr Anderson suffered "a mental condition".

Mental condition, thy name is Islam.
Posted by: badanov   2004-08-31 8:12:09 AM  

00:00