You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Israel-Palestine
Some Arab Israelis find fence beneficial
2004-07-10
The 26-foot-high concrete and razor wire barrier down the hill from Najeh Abu Mukh's house cuts him off from relatives and the West Bank. But the Arab Israeli gas-station worker said he doesn't mind, because the controversial Israeli barrier has done something years of failed peace talks have not: It has taken the bloody Israeli-Palestinian conflict away from his home. Like many Arab Israeli citizens who live in northern Israel along the security barrier erected earlier this year, Abu Mukh agrees with the Israeli government that it's beneficial. The Israeli military claims the barrier has cut suicide attacks coming from the now-enclosed northern West Bank by 90 percent. Abu Mukh questioned the International Court of Justice ruling Friday that condemned it as illegal and inhumane. "I'm wondering if the judges ever have been here or lived here and understand the real reason for its construction," the 30-year-old asked, relaxing on his front porch with a cup of sweet Arabic coffee. "If not, they should listen and not judge."

Arab Israelis don't readily share this sentiment with outsiders. They fear getting killed appearing disloyal to their Palestinian brethren, who live across the line separating Israel from Palestinian territory and hate the structure as much as they despise the government that built it, Arab Israeli journalist Hassan Mawsi explains. The route the Israeli Defense Ministry selected for the barrier, which places large chunks of Palestinian land on the Israeli side, adds to Palestinian anger. A row of homes that was once in Palestinian Baqa al Sharghiya, or Baqa East, in now in Baqa al Gharbiya, or Baqa West. "Eight of our houses are now cut off from our village and two of them were destroyed so this thing could be built," said Palestinian Riyadh Hussein, 28, gesturing at the security barrier, which he now must walk around to take his three children to nursery school. But Arab Israelis, like their Jewish counterparts, wanted relief from the suicide bombings and gun attacks that have killed 980 Israeli citizens during the nearly four-year Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Five of 21 people killed by a suicide bomber at an Arab- and Jewish-owned restaurant last October in Haifa, for example, were Arab Israeli.
Is it something about living in Israel proper that puts some sense into the heads of Arabs?
Their dilemma was compounded because attackers often crossed into Israel through Arab hamlets such as Baqa al Gharbiya, blending in with hundreds of undocumented workers and clashing with the heavily armed Israeli border guards who tried to ferret them out. A particularly frightening experience - Abu Mukh and his mother, Hanifa, 71, recounted - occurred in March 2002, when police stopped a suicide attacker's vehicle at a checkpoint in their town. An Israeli policeman and the two Palestinian gunmen in the car were killed in an ensuing shootout. "All the time Israeli border guards would come here to search for Palestinians who had come illegally," the younger Abu Mukh recalled. "That meant we, too, were repeatedly subjected to identity card checks and questions. I couldn't even go to the store at night without being checked." There was no such tension evident Friday afternoon in his sleepy neighborhood, where the only sound came from bees and a lone Israeli Humvee that drove along the barrier road.
Posted by:trailing wife / AoS

#10  Interesting while stating that not supporting Pals can get an Israeli Arab killed, the story is quick to give his name and occupation and virtual location away.
Posted by: Chris Smith   2004-07-10 7:51:37 PM  

#9  It's going to be interesting to see if the Jewish vote in New York can see through this smoke screen of hers. She will have to defend her seat before 2008 and I wonder how she will do?
Posted by: Cyber Sarge   2004-07-10 3:58:24 PM  

#8  FNC has been running a crawl - tho no story - all morning that the Paleos are demanding that the UN 'enforce' the non-binding ruling. The Paleo PM (can't remember his name) is making threatening noises suggesting that the Paleos may have to tear down the wall themselves.
Go for it, guys. INVADE Israel and see how much fun you have.

PS - you guys think they're insane NOW? Wait till Israel gets the anti-rocket defenses up (hint: laser towers, with weapons that have already been successfully tested against Katyushas.) and they can't even do that anymore. Seething would be considered a step up.

Mike
Posted by: Mike Kozlowski   2004-07-10 2:26:50 PM  

#7  The route the Israeli Defense Ministry selected for the barrier, which places large chunks of Palestinian land on the Israeli side, adds to Palestinian anger.

What on earth doesn't 'add(s) to Palestinian anger'?
Posted by: Raj   2004-07-10 1:32:41 PM  

#6  Of *course* hillary is supporting the wall. She doesn't want her ass tossed out of office by the NY electorate.
Posted by: Brutus   2004-07-10 12:54:31 PM  

#5  
"I'm wondering if the judges ever have been here or lived here and understand the real reason for its construction"
Of course not, Abu. Leave their pampered cocoon and come to your "shitty little country"?

You must not get out much.
Posted by: Barbara Skolaut   2004-07-10 10:45:43 AM  

#4  Try this Yahoo! News - Audio/Video link for a list that contained the clip as of today.

This is a direct link that should trigger the file being played. Hillary is about half-way through the clip.

Pretty interesting, and not at all nuanced.
Posted by: cingold   2004-07-10 8:20:39 AM  

#3  Try this Yahoo! News - Audio/Video link for a list that contained the clip as of today.

This is a direct link that should trigger the file being played.

Pretty interesting, and not at all nuanced.
Posted by: cingold   2004-07-10 8:18:48 AM  

#2  First I've heard of it,Muck.I find it hard to believe Hillary at supports something that makes sense.
Posted by: Raptor   2004-07-10 8:04:48 AM  

#1  ok. ima leave this up you guys. i am been seeing all over blogosphere tonite that hillary clinton is defend the wall today and is blame the u.n. for whole mess. the left are piss with her and i am hear that there no link, but it on cnn. they are piss with her and think she is up in shenanigans and are pissed. ima have my own view on all this ifn it true but was trying find link but cant find any. is anyone have a link anywhere for this or hear about it?
Posted by: muck4doo   2004-07-10 5:07:43 AM  

00:00