| Submit your comments on this article |
| International-UN-NGOs |
| Claudia Rosset lampoons, then skewers UN |
| 2004-06-16 |
| WSJ - EFL From the woman who has kicked UN ass like no other, Claudia Rosset. Turtle Bay’s Latest Coverup The U.N. investigates itself--again. BY CLAUDIA ROSETT Wednesday, June 16, 2004 12:01 a.m. EDT In a stunning development that even the United Nations’ fiercest critics will surely hail as a turn for the better, Secretary-General Kofi Annan announced yesterday that he is "entirely disgusted" with the way the U.N. investigates itself. "It’s a way of deflecting criticism, not solving problems," said Mr. Annan, adding that "The U.N. Secretariat has become a secret society, swathed in privilege and shielded by immunities. As secretary-general, tasked with upholding the integrity, values and moral authority of the United Nations, I am authorizing a new policy of complete transparency, financial and otherwise, in the workings of the Secretariat, starting with full disclosure of all internal debates, correspondence, memos, audits, expense accounts and cafeteria subsidies. Oh, and by the way, I apologize for presiding over the biggest swindle in the history of humanitarian relief, the Oil-for-Food program in Iraq." Just kidding. This is raw fantasy; Mr. Annan never said any such thing. In the real world, in the best tradition of setting bureaucratic backfires, the U.N. has now labored mightily, in collaboration with Deloitte Consulting LLP, to add one more item to the recent series of U.N. self-investigations--this one an inquiry into the U.N. Secretariat’s perception of its own integrity. The resulting public document, which runs to 90 pages but somehow omits what were reportedly some lurid individual responses, was posted recently on Mr. Annan’s U.N. web page under the title "United Nations Organizational Integrity Survey 2004." Though readers must slog through such U.N.-speak as "The U.N. wanted to operationalize integrity," this report has its intriguing moments. Somewhere under it simmers a certain candor. The findings are based on responses from 6,086 of the 18,035 U.N. Secretariat employees to whom the survey questionnaire on U.N. integrity was sent--meaning about one-third of the staff weighed in, which is enough to be significant. The results, summed up in a cover letter by Mr. Annan, suggest that the Secretariat’s own employees believe they inhabit a snake pit. Highlights, as Mr. Annan cites them, include such failings as: "integrity and ethical behavior are not taken sufficiently into account in selection, promotion and assessment processes" and "staff believe that not enough action is taken to investigate and address instances of unethical behavior, and that those who expose such breaches may put themselves at risk of reprisal." More directly to the point, the report itself, on page 11, notes that "staff members feel unprotected from reprisals for reporting violations of the codes of conduct. This is not a perception confined to a few staff in remote locales and/or dangerous circumstances. Forty-six percent (46%) gave unfavourable response to this item, while only 12% gave favourable responses." ...more... Rosset rocks. Typically well-constructed fact-filled authoritative piece delivered with tongue planted firmly in cheek. Me love Claudia, heh. |
| Posted by:.com |
| #3 Getting a response rate of about 35% by itself implies an organization with severe morale problems. Typically, the non responders are beaten down and too demoralized to respond or else are hoping to lay low until they retire or are too lazy to respond or too distrustful of the organization to respond or maybe too stupid to figure out how to respond. |
| Posted by: mhw 2004-06-16 10:03:21 AM |
| #2 Thwart the probe? I wouldn't put it past those folks to have already destroyed most of the incriminating evidence in the oil-for-food scandal. These UN people are starting to look more clownish and twisted than Zhirnovsky. |
| Posted by: jules 187 2004-06-16 9:36:02 AM |
| #1 This combined with the news about Dileep Nair (from NY Post: the undersecretary general in charge of the U.N. Office of Internal Oversight, has been accused of demanding kickbacks and sexual favors in return for promotions inside his office. Nair...also has been accused of attempting to thwart the probe into the Iraq oil-for-food scandal). Now if we can just pull a couple more bricks out of the foundation......CRASH! |
| Posted by: Spot 2004-06-16 9:08:14 AM |