You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Russia
McNamara: Nuclear War Still Possible; NY No. 1 Target
2004-04-27
The threat of devastating nuclear attack by Russia against the United States has not diminished, warns former Sec. of Defense Robert McNamara. Writing in Monday’s Los Angeles Times, McNamara and co-author Helen Caldicott claim that the threat of a nuclear catastrophe remains real, “whether by accident, human fallibility or malfeasance.”
Ohfergawdsake. Helen Caldicott. Wotta maroon.
The Soviet Union collapsed on itself and the divide between Eastern communism and Western democracy disintegrated more than 13 years ago. Because of that, the nightmare scenario is not on the minds of many Americans today.
Nor of the Russians. As it happens, we're in similar boats, though not the same one, and chances of war between the two states are minuscule for the foreseeable future...
Nevertheless, the threat remains serious, McNamara and Caldicott argue, because, despite the end of the Cold War in the early 1990's, thousands of Russian nuclear warheads are still pointed at the U.S. targeting many civilian population centers.
I'd prefer they were pointed at Mecca and Medina and Karachi, myself. I'd wager some of them are, too...
McNamara, defense secretary to presidents Kennedy and Johnson, U.S. and Caldicott, a pediatrician and head of the Nuclear Policy Research Institute, say that Russian nuclear targeting strategies haven't changed much — and certainly not enough to reflect the thaw in relations between both nations.
We keep hearing about Vietnam and quagmires. McNamara's the guy who brought on the quagmire. And we're supposed to listen to him on this? And Caldecott's an outright crank.
The pair also cite a January 2002 document from the U.S. Foreign Military Studies Office at Fort Leavenworth, Kan., titled, "Prototypes for Targeting America, a Soviet Military Assessment." The study reports that New York City is the single most important target after military installations on the U.S. Atlantic coast.
At the moment, there's a lot more chance of turbans being involved in anything terrible that happens to New York. Perhaps McNamara and Caldecott should apply some of his management principles and get their priorities straight.
Posted by:Mark Espinola

#14  "You guys do know that Rumsfeld was one of the youngest of the Whiz Kids, right?"

Bullshit.
All 10 of the so-called Whiz-kids had been Army Air Force officers in WW2 (when Rumsfeld was still a child) and all had worked at Ford with McNamara.
Rumsfeld never worked for Ford and did not serve in the Kennedy/Johnson DoD. He was elected to Congress in 1962, just a year after McNamara became Secdef. He stayed in Congress until 1971, two years after LBJ had left office.
He had left the Navy in 1957 and served as a Congressional staffer and worked for an investment firm until his election to Congress.
Posted by: Atomic Conspiracy   2004-04-27 9:44:11 PM  

#13  Thanks 11A5S. People forget, I was famous once. I didn't get smaller, the vision did.

Posted by: TFX   2004-04-27 1:11:06 PM  

#12  TFX: Almost missed that one. Good, but very obscure.
Posted by: 11A5S   2004-04-27 12:12:52 PM  

#11  If McNamara says the Russians are going to nuke NYC, I'd start buying real estate there.
Posted by: 11A5S   2004-04-27 12:11:19 PM  

#10  He's just doing it to advertise his new Florida based 1-900 Psychic Tip line.
Posted by: Anonymoose   2004-04-27 11:48:25 AM  

#9  When I was very young I assumed Johnson & McNamara knew what they were doing, too. I also inhaled. Oh, wait, that's redundant.
Posted by: .com   2004-04-27 11:01:57 AM  

#8  You guys do know that Rumsfeld was one of the youngest of the Whiz Kids, right?
Posted by: rkb   2004-04-27 10:35:44 AM  

#7  He's come full cirle: drinks Ensure and wears Depends. You know, when you make it back to diapers and pablum, well, you've been here too long.

But this asshole is "special"... he should've had a close encounter with a friendly frag 35-40 yrs ago.
Posted by: .com   2004-04-27 10:11:33 AM  

#6  ..Hey Bob, good to see ya!... STFU and drive yer freakin' Edsel!!!!
The DOD is in some ways still trying to shake off the damage this idiot did forty years ago. Either ignore him or tell him to follow the example of SecDef Forrestal.

Mike
Posted by: Mike Kozlowski   2004-04-27 9:45:18 AM  

#5  More proof that there ain't no justice: this old war criminal and human disaster area is still with us.

As JFK's secdef, this pompous fool brought in a crowd of "whiz-kids," academic analysts, to revamp every aspect of Pentagon operations, from procurement and planning to tactical doctrine, for heaven's sake.

He was utterly convinced that he and his gang had all the answers, and that their conclusions should trump professional advice in every case.
The result was a national disaster whose consequences still haunt our national life to this day.

McNamara admitted, finally, that he had been wrong about Vietnam, but his mea culpa largely reflects standard lefty doctrine about the war, and ignores the real cause: the supreme arrogance and stupidity of his own tenure at the Pentagon.
Posted by: Atomic Conspiracy   2004-04-27 9:39:21 AM  

#4  RC, be nice. Based on the article, he's spent 13 years figuring this out... :-)
Posted by: snellenr   2004-04-27 9:23:32 AM  

#3  Don't be sooo mean to Sec. Mac. I miss him. I culda been a contenda.
Posted by: TFX   2004-04-27 8:44:21 AM  

#2  Whatever dude, just keep yourself and your damn "advice" away from all planning at the Pentagon.
Posted by: Laurence of the Rats   2004-04-27 8:13:55 AM  

#1  Wow! What a flashingly obvious piece of insight!

Future headlines:

McNamara: Muslims Hate Jews

McNamara: Water is Wet

McNamara: I Wet Myself
Posted by: Robert Crawford   2004-04-27 8:10:06 AM  

00:00