You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Middle East
ElBaradei calls on Israel to give up nukes
2003-12-12
The Director General of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), Mohamed ElBaradei, has called on Israel to relinquish its nuclear weapons as part of a general peace agreement in the Middle East. In an interview with Haaretz, ElBaradei said Israel should follow the path taken by South Africa, the first and only country to part from its nuclear cache, when its weapons were destroyed under IAEA supervision in 1989. In his first interview with the Israeli media, ElBaradei said he recommends that Israel join the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT). He said that in spite of Israel’s policy of not acknowledging possession of nuclear weapons, "we operate under the assumption that Israel has nuclear arms. Israel has never denied this," he said from his office at Vienna headquarters of the UN organization.

The senior UN diplomat said the notion that Israel is safer today with nuclear weapons than it was 50 years ago is incorrect. "Frankly, I am not happy with the status quo, because I see a lot of frustration in the Middle East due to Israel’s sitting on nuclear weapons or nuclear weapons capability, while other parties in the Middle East are committed to the NPT," he said. The Egyptian diplomat, who has headed the IAEA for seven years, suggested that Israel and its neighbors begin a dialogue for the eradication of weapons of mass destruction. "My fear is that without such a dialogue, there will be continued incentive for the region’s countries to develop weapons of mass destruction to match the Israeli arsenal, and as you know, there are already weapons of mass destruction in the region," he said. "Israel has nuclear, maybe biological and chemical [weapons]; others have biological weapons. It’s not an incentive for security in the region."
Posted by:TS

#7  We will give away our nuclear arsenal on the same day the US does!
How's that as a way of saying "never"?
Posted by: The Dodo   2003-12-13 5:36:58 AM  

#6  If there's a general peace agreement, sure.

I'm not holding my breath though and as critical as I am about the Greater Israel crowd it's not as though I expect anyone to slit their own throats.
Posted by: Hiryu   2003-12-12 11:11:20 AM  

#5  How about "no", Mohamed? Ok?
Posted by: mojo   2003-12-12 10:54:28 AM  

#4  "we operate under the assumption that Israel has nuclear arms. Israel has never denied this,"

And this doesn't apply for Iran because...?
Posted by: Charles   2003-12-12 10:54:19 AM  

#3  "What nukes?"
Posted by: snellenr   2003-12-12 9:55:17 AM  

#2  Israel has previously expressed an interest in a regional disarmament conference. This would have to be attended by Israel and ALL other major powers in the region, including Saudi Arabia and Iran. Since these latter two states refuse to allow their representatives to sit in the same room with an Israeli representative, this is an unrealistic option for now.


That is the barrier to the dialogue El Baradei suggests - I do not see El Baradei coming up with a constructive means to advance that dialogue.
Posted by: liberalhawk   2003-12-12 9:19:34 AM  

#1  How bout I call on ElBaradei to stop being such an incompetent arse with his head stuck in the sand? That seems fair right?
Posted by: Val   2003-12-12 8:49:14 AM  

00:00