You have commented 274 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Middle East
Israeli Ministers steer clear of new ’Geneva’ deal
2003-10-13
JPost Reg req’d - this "deal" is a suicide pact
Not a single minister in Prime Minister Ariel Sharon’s cabinet is expected to support the Geneva Initiative hammered out over the weekend by a team of Israeli leftists and Palestinians in Amman. Former Justice Minister Yossi Beilin, who initiated the plan, had expressed hope of attracting support from Shinui and Likud MKs. The two sides in Amman agreed to bring the deal to their governments for approval. But Shinui leader Yosef (Tommy) Lapid released a statement criticizing the initiative and National Infrastructure Minister Yosef Partitzky, who considers himself the most dovish minister, said he also opposes the plan. "Every effort must be made to encourage dialogue with the Palestinians but this must be done by the elected government and not a gathering of failed politicians like Beilin, [Amram] Mitzna, and [Avraham] Burg," Lapid said. "The Geneva Initiative entails far-reaching concessions that should not even be made at the end of negotiations and certainly not at the beginning. The Palestinians accepted the ’road map,’ making many more concessions, and there is no reason for Israel to give them up. In the end, [the initiative] is an irresponsible move, even from the point of view of those who seek peace." The farthest Left Shinui MKs, Ilan Lebovich and Eti Livni, were involved in earlier stages of planning the Geneva Initiative, but have not seen the final result and have not yet decided whether to back it.

Note: The deal would give the Paleos control over the Temple Mount with International oversight, while the Paleos would renounce the "right of return" — which they never have, and never will. The country’s borders would return to’67, yadda yadda... The deal is even too much for Shimon Peres to sign on — should tell you something. IMHO, you can’t "deal" with those who lie, cheat, and break every treaty or agreement they’ve ever signed.
Posted by:Frank G

#6  That's right, Anonymous: the Mooselims have no real claim on Jerusalem; all Mohammed ever talked about in the Qu'ran was the "far mosque" which is usually understood to be Medina, but in Yassir's mind and that of his other jihadi killers it's Jerusalem.
Just another Islamist claim to drive Jews and the rest of the Western world crazy.
Posted by: Jennie Taliaferro   2003-10-13 10:58:55 PM  

#5  Didn't some Egyptian historians just publish an article saying that they think Mohammed's flight was not to Jerusalem but to Medina?

No claim to the Mount.
Posted by: Anonymous   2003-10-13 10:37:53 PM  

#4  Ok I guess I was wrong - the JPost reports that the PA has endorsed the proposal, so it must be OK.....rriiggghhhht

"Palestinian Minister Yasser Abed Rabbo, who led the Palestinian delegation in the negotiations over the unofficial Geneva Initiative, said on Monday the PA endorses the draft agreement"
Posted by: Frank G   2003-10-13 7:32:44 PM  

#3  just wait tho': Jimmy Carter and Ramsey Clark are sure to speak out
Posted by: Frank G   2003-10-13 3:03:59 PM  

#2  ..and not a gathering of failed politicians like Beilin, [Amram] Mitzna, and [Avraham] Burg," Lapid said.

Toss Shimon Arafat-still-deserves-his-Nobel-Prize Peres into that group and the listing of failed politicians is complete.
Posted by: Bomb-a-rama   2003-10-13 2:42:21 PM  

#1  Wow, Frank! Every minister agreeing on a matter like this?! Even Peres?

Now we're living in strange, strange days....
Posted by: Dripping Sarcasm   2003-10-13 1:36:37 PM  

00:00